very nice work on the bottle

Simple and straightforward. Red is sexy. Good work!

very nice minus the box

The image is too dark. If you had lightened the background, even to grey, it would put more emphasis on the product ( the bottles). Just my opinion.

Good job author. Try to invest more in the transparency effect, but the idea is brilliant.

I like the envy bottle being the color of green! Nice idea.

wicked, love texturing of the bottle just put in the box and u r done

Uau! Moving the things! Congratulations, very creative!

Good job, but you gave more emphasis to the environment than the bottle of perfume that is the high point in this contest.

The color palette is kind of visually jarring, too much green, which is overpowering what should be your focal point, the bottle...The logo on the bottle is too small and blurry looking. The box looks somewhat blurry, as well, with what appears to be a "dent" in the lower RH corner, but does not correspond to the sharp edges.

I'd suggest cropping it down (or making your focal point occupy at least 1/2 of your picture plane), and change the tone of that green, perhaps darkening it at least.

Agree with MossyB, also the liquid should be visilbe within the bottle..

I hope it's better now

It's a good start. Note the work of other participants and study the features of transparency and shadow. The picture looks a little blurry. Go ahead