Pretty realistic looking, nice job.

thank you! I try

wow, I thought it was a picture for a sec. Had to look at the SBS to believe it, well done =)

thank you

well done ....that looks so good ..can u bake me a batch?

Amazing! Wow!

Perfect job, congrasts!!

looks like a slightly distorted version of the reference image with a few brush scatterings for "authenticity" to me.

Check the sbs

I always do, hence the comment

So its still not authentic ?

I agree with Geexman. If you see the picture in the sbs, where in some of the steps you can find some large pieces of the image, it seems that the autor painted right over a photo. You can clearly see that is a photo by watching the cracks of the cookie.
If you compare the source image with the painted version, you will see that there are no big differences except for few strokes with the dotted brush that the autor used for texturing the surface.
Sorry for my bad english!

pfft sorry for being too accurate... my other drawing I made sure I had every step to insure to not be accused of cheating.... I strive for realism. That one people also thought a photo..... :P

there is also a thing called a ruler in ps.....

Congrats!

Thank you Loopyluv

Congrats!!

thanx!

Oh Boy looks good enough to eat... Congrats