Nice shot, but I don't know how picky folks want to get. That's a rose, not a red (as your description says)

A good drop.

nice effort.......but, the flash is too harsh, and there are disturbing prints on the glass......

Agree with Ade about the flash.....but a nice effort...

I agree, the flash kills the depth of your picture.

flash definitely killed the shot.

Ops, I spilt a whole glass on the carpet during this contest. Covered the spill with lots of potatoe flour, left it to th enext morning, and vaccumed it ALL of. Not a sign of the wine stain.

its looks out of fucus but the way the actual wine looks it kind of works for me

It is O.O.F. I would try this shot again but try the macro setting on your camera.

Yes, I drank to much of it, photo soft , eyes well O.O.F. not just the camera. Great exercise, enjoyed it.
On the wagon again.
Have fresh supply of wine, will give it another go.
I gave it another go, not as oof as the last one.
has been a fun exercise.

Nice try...

It's still OOF. Why don't you photograph the wine before you drink it?

More of the bg than the wine comes into focus...

it sems in focus but the flash is too much reflecting.