A bit too "target centered." It looks like a snapshot, without much real visual interest. Even though you have a nice range of values, the composition hurts this photo.

Put it off centre now...

Looks a bit better and more visually dynamic.

Great shot! Its so hard to photograph the moon

Thankyou very much
That it is!

Author, did you upload the wrong photo? It appears to be some sort of "snap" taken by accident...I would hope someone of your obvious talent didn't enter this on purpose?!?

It's tilting somewhat hard to the right, I'd suggest leveling it a bit...

changed pics...this one is small but i didnt know what to replace tribeca with

It's kind of blurry.