yes they were scanned. I'm sorry. Had no choice.

Great illusion!

HOly crap!

I'm a little confused about the "or not" part and rbsgrl's comment about it being a great illusion. What am I missing here?

Its one of those shots where one object is close and one is far so it looks like the jellyfish is the size of the human. You have to have an imagination to see stuff like that sometimes.

"Forced Perspective"

oh, I thought Jellyfish got that big? See what I know

This is lovely and very relaxing, I would however, darken the image and increase the contrast.That would make the people more in silhouettes and increase the colour and clarity of the water and fish.

A harsh flash rarely gives a great photo. The shadows on the left also detract from the photo. I'm not convinced that this portrays 'obesity' the meal looks quite healthy and if the person is fat, we don't see enough of him/her to tell.

Thanks for the comment!
it was a very good critique i appreciate it

I'd say its technically on theme (the man in the picture is obviously a larger person) but I agree that it could have been implemented a bit better. Maybe reshoot and resubmit?

Agree with both! it does look a bit healthy to me and the flash is a bit distracting but i believe it is on theme! well done author