There is something about this photo I really like, it has a haunting feel.

Haunting feel not such if that was what I was going for when photographing my horse.

Nice idea, but there seem to be a dirty streak across the window.

Ya, but you still can't see the window and you can tell it's on glass.

Read th eguide lines again, and it does say, appears ALMOST invisable. so in actual fact you are probably far more on theme that the entries, where you can't see the glass at all.

That's what I thought

Nice idea - well done

I think it would have been perfect if you couldn't see the dirty streaks on the window because you wouldn't be able to see the glass, but you know it'd be there because of the writing.

But you still can't see the window but you know there's a window. I personally think that is why this entry is more on theme, as friiskiwi said, because you can tell it's on glass, even though it's smeared, but cannot see the glass it's self. I think a glare or reflection with be a view of the glass.

I agree.......you don't see the window, but you do see what is on it!