very nice work !

Nice idea, but too blown out...

The two birds are a cool concept. Constructive criticism would be that the bright clouds might have too much contrast and brightness.

i hope it`s better now.. thanks

Love it!, i really dont know why, but the skyline doesnt fit whit the image, maybe replace it whit another image?, try to figure out something

Nice job...shadow of black horse needs adjusting.

REALLY nice blend! some of the lighting is a little off on the horses, but very pretty, and you have a great eye for composition.

very nice done

The white horse on the left shoultnt really have a shine from it, its in the shade.

Maybe change the horse on the left completely because its also out of perspective.

I will check the details you suggest to change later. Thank you for comments.

I would remove the horse in lower left corner. The lighting is wrong, the perspective is wrong and it does nothing for an otherwise great composition.

very nice entry good luck

Image of left horse removed.! Thank you for suggestions

Horses look very small to me, and i feel like the shadows should also be softer, but it's a great blend, especially the stream. Good luck!

Light sources are opposite...

nice, but contrast is not good

It's looks very realistic, so good luck to you!

The shadows on the road are odd. Conflicting light sources.

You could;ve worked a bit more on masking out the leaves on the left, but still, a very nice image. Good luck.

good idea!

Good idea, but light on deer is opposite the original light source...

Fixed it a bit.

No, you'd have to flip the deer to change the light so much. Light source is from upper left.

Well it looks like to me the light source is coming from the center.

Does it? Is that why the shadows are on our left & the highlights are on our right?

CMYK is right about the shadows. I was going to say somethng earlier about the right rocks and girl layered in but it seems you've improved that.

OK Thanks for all of your suggestions! I flipped the deer to match the light source! And Nator, the image looks kinda poor without the girl... But I guess it was IYO :P

The girl is fine, IMHO and I think you did a fine chop.GL!

]

why light on the golf ball?

Thank you for comment jaescoe21, just trying to highlight the ball in the darker part of the picture, removed the glow hope you like the change, cheers.

Way too much blur...and why only on half of the figure?

Thanks for your comment CMYK46 reduced the blur hope you like the change.

i think this is much better... great job. if you do want to highlight the ball and you feel like you need an outer glow you can add just a little. what you had was to much. gl

It's very well chopped, original and unique, so good luck to you author!

Nice shot, I mean image