nice image choices, but it doesn't really have the pop-up feel to it. well, except for the clouds

agrees with elficho

agrees with elficho

get a brain....... and be constructive... how did either of you help me?

IMO...your letters stand out a little too much, and the shadows aren't connected in some areas, and some have none at all. I don't see how they would pop up when the book is opened, but the actual building is well put together, and makes sense. I think you could have spent some time on the pages of the book because the two don't work together... and you thought about the pull tabs even if they are a little flimsy... on the whole though a very good effort GL

off theme, just looks like a building plonked on top of a giant book LOL

that's just because it's the only element... and doesn't blend well with the pages... that's why it looks so 'plonked' (lol)

its to copy/paste and should be blended way better...but i like the idea

nice idea , good luck.

Thank you for source images: (1) book & (2)table------ nkzs

Sorry, I agree with barnacle. This isn't a pop up book.

the background is pretty distracting... dare i say that it's more 'on theme' than some of the others... ???? gl

yes, would you dare?

Yes I believe I have!

@JamesD.. I'm still giggling about you being called a DONK..WTF is a DONK?.. hehehehe

Foreground & background are both distracting...the focus should be on the contest elements, which are somewhat confusing...

color from background borrowed from the water images... color for the table borrowed from the swans beaks.. print version looks fabulous.. so I'm going to keep it as is...

(the 11x15 print version has no back lighting.. so High Res isn't really what the image looks like)

My first thought on 'donk' was the character in Crocodile Dundee... the dumb looking strong guy... lol.

Donk is short for Donkey, widely used around the poker scene, quite fitting imo

Thanks Barnacle

My pleasure

we should bo polite for each other.we should learn always to be better.

This really doesn't look like a popup book. You can tell it was chopped in and not layered well.

i agree with you but i did my best sorry

I think it would help if you put a crease along the boat where it would be folded when the book closed. Also attaching the bird to the boat will make it look more like a real pop up. Here's a link to a good tut for adding creases if you need help http://www.planetphotoshop.com/folds-and-creases.html

I 've followed your advices and go to the tutoriel that sundevil356 gave to me hope it's look better now ! Thanks

This looked a lot better before your edit.

I think you just added too much folds, there's no need to put folds on your boat or bird, only the water needed folds? and u might want to get rid of the blurred stuff coming over the edges of the page? anyway I hope you make it a bit better, the idea is good, but u can still work on the presentation.

Maybe less folding, if it had that many folds in it, then it wouldnt pop out of the book. Good idea though, goodluck.

good idea but image mixing is not looks...

dont understand how this would work as a pop up book!...

Unfortunately the globe takes most of the attention away from the book. Perhaps you could crop the image to make the pop-up the focal point. Oh and a high-res would be nice too.

i don't realy see it but is there a shadow of the flower? that would make it look a lot more realistic...

nice one

needs a tab of some sort if it was going to pop up

agrees with Ray Tedwell