the idea is neat.. but where the sky is darker so should the grass

don't see any of the wine bottle image -- SBS might help

I don't get it...the SBS says that he filled the bottle black and fitted it with the shadow. I think that effectively makes it invisible. Interesting idea with the boat, though.

I'm with you on the boat sky placement gamemastertips... it's quite stunning... but I admire ANYONE who entered this contest.. It's daring just to attempt it (I have 2 started Ideas that I just gave up on because I knew I wouldn't have time to finish them)

IMO the bottle source isn't used. Anything can be turned black and made into a shadow.

No wine bottles, no dial bad and your SBS tells me nothing.

this looks pretty much the exact same as an earlier entry....... kinda disappointed at the lack of originality

I don't think he copied it. He wouldn't have had enough time between the two entries...but, what do I know. :/

Oh and the water looks a bit unrealistic...and the boat reflection is a little off...and the perspective of the blanket is a bit off too. Sorry...

I agree with both... the blanket is on slant so how a bottle is going to be like that..? you could move that above then it'll be good... good luck..

I don't think it was copied... I just think the ideas are too similar, but thats my opinion

Okay I see, Jello. So who's to blame for being unoriginal then? The first guy or this guy? lol

no one really. just imo I wouldn't upload an entry soo close in comparison .. just my own opinion and yes I have changed entries before due to another similar entry being posted

Well, I guess it's a pretty common idea that would've sprung to mind. :/ Picnic cloth...pond with water...at least the meter guard and shadows are different.

Nice work....

perspective problems...and am i going blind ...i can't find the keypad!

some am I.. yea where is the dialpad..? nice catch PixelWhisperer...

He used the star key to make the flowers...I know....

woaw.. nice thinking author and nice catch gamemastertips.. thanks for showing me where it was used..

Hehe no prob. I would have never seen it. It was in the SBS.

try to blend the harsh line between the grass and the rest of the sky

I agree with ponti; need a better blend between colors.

Do you mean the yellower line that goes from the left and ends on the house? If it's that. Thast's suposed to be a reflector.

?

y is that reflector needed..? and ponti meant about the ground level.. from where the house starts.. or the line where the base of the tree on the right is..