Very interesting take on the source and well done!

gud job........

i love this...totally different approach but so cool final result...gl

The dogs need some shadows, and i would also shrink them down slightly, they seem a bit too big at the moment. Watch out for opposing light sources too (the man and the dogs) I'd flip the man horizontally to match the lighting on the background.

Good luck

Or make the man bigger and add some shadows to the dogs.

very cool mood but i agree about the size of the dogs...i know is a bit to lat now, but this image had a lot of perspective....gl author

wow.. nice work.. i like the reflection of the dog on the water.. GL

and i think you should work on the edge..

wonderfully thought out author..tiny nit pic... straighten out the edge along the white leg of the maroon jockey (It's great just the way it is.. but if you clean that tiny edge you will get much higher votes..) great concept and well executed...

The edge all the right down to the boot along the dog is just a bit hurdy gurdy but the overall creation is very well done

This is a good idea at the base.

the enges are a bit too rough, but it's a good idea and execution otherwise

Why is the puppy so big compared to the plane

think you did well ! Could blur the plane a bit though
GL

Not only is the dog too distorted, but it would be behind the plane, not in front.