The bricks need to be aligned at the corners & the figure on our right should be flipped to match the light source. If you want to follow a tut, at least try to get the basics right.

Sorry but the walls and steps do not look right, a shame because i like the idea, maybe you could try to correct it

Well it's not entirely your fault, cause the author of the tutorial had some problems with the perspective. That entrace should follow the horizontal lines between the bricks, instead the entire opening in the original is ambiguous, in reality it would make no sense.
However you should be more carefull at step 6, the second part, where it said that the gaps should match., and the stairs should be from wall to wall.

If you have probs. with proportions, use the final result of the tut., and draw some guide lines over it. Use them to build your entry on top.

Thanks greymval Yeah i was having some difficulties with that, I think I will be drawing them instead. Will edit asap, thanks again !

Nice attempt at a difficult tutorial. I can see you put some effort into this and it is a learning process ... that is what tutorials are for, right? I think greymval's suggestion are valid and helpful.

Top work author...well done

Tutorial was followed well, but, being as the transparency is within water there would definitley be some refraction of the background (select donkey shape and liquify-bloat brush inside selection on the background layer) ....& to add a little extra I`d make the ground under the donkey darker/wetter (maybe using soft burn brush).... just a thought

nice1

Hmmm.. Thanx for the idea Geexman! I'll try it just to see the result. I should have thought of that before...!

Interesting image and I am glad to see an "easy" way to make thing transparent (ha ha)... nice run at it! I do agree with Geexman but not bad work overall!

Nice....I did the tut as well.

Nice one...gl

wow! simply awesome! carry on!

sources please

I like this, it makes me happy looking at it = )

Very cool and colourful

It's seems so simple but it's so cool! Definite fav! GL!

Would love to see hi res if you can ... it looks like you did a pretty good job but hard to tell with the little image ... I will wait to vote in hopes you can get a hi res uploaded (doesn't have to be huge ... even 900x600 would be better and that is way under 1MB).

sorry forgot to tick the box thankyou

Much better ... fun image!

Sources???? what was the original tutorial you followed?

ok, found the source, its inside the SBS.

Its a nice looking picture, but it doesnt look like a sketch as the tutorial says its suposed to be. to me it looks more like you just simply made the image black and white. and then used a spackle texture over it and faded some of the rest out.

Ive seen other work of yours and i think you can do so much better on this tutorial. GL author.

I agree