That is kinda neat

Thank you

Very subtle, yet moving...well done.

Very nicely done!

desert storm with two flat and happy soldiers, there was war...

These two soldiers knew they were in a war. They were smiling at the cameras for their families back home. This was BEFORE the internet.. when letters were still sent out in regular mail and they didn't know when the photo would get home, but at least their families would know that at the time the photo was taken, that they were ok..

Soldier image is not proper selected, white border are visible and hand is not proper cropped.

Try to remove the white artifacts (Filter/noise/dust & scratches and/or Clone tool). Rather than selecting with the magic wand tool, use the pen tool or lasso tool to get clean edges. Also, you need to post the uncut original photo in a step-by-step guide.
I'm guessing the first commenter is referring to the cut off elbow, which could be fixed by cropping the image at right & eliminating the dead space.

The edges of the figure are a lot better. The area inside the arm against the flag still has white edges, and there are still a lot of white artifacts all over in hi-res.

You should try to color correct the soldier's skin tones - they are too warm and yellow for the rest of the image.

Additionally, the lower part of the uniform is noticeably lighter than the rest of him. Making a selection of his uniform, and going to Image>Adjustments>Selective Color>Whites, and increasing the Black slider should help that.

IM seeing some good improvements here author.. keep it up !

I strongly salute the soldier as any other that fights for their country and the right thing. The critique stated here has nothing against the soldier but rather the put together of this image. They are only trying to help you improve areas that might not have had as much attn to details as it should. Again there is nothing against the brave soldier, just some areas that need improvement on the "total image". Don't get so defensive. Try to embrace free help from great talent. I like the idea of what you have done and composition with the pledge but please consider their ideas.

face is green, white edges of costume, flat.

Thanks for the comment Gransbergis