Nice overall feel on this one. I like the lighting on this, but I would've liked to see a shadow on the ground next to the rock formation on the lower left side. Good luck!

Magical!
Must be viewed in high resolution!

awesome and well done... You may want to crop out the dead area of black on the left side.. I know you have that great rock at the bottom but if you cropped that side out.. the story would really POP!!! (this is all IMHO... great job author and good luck)

Nice image. The light source is a little confusing, but overall, great job!

i don't get the light source either, but a nice blend

I don't mind really the light (source) being a bit 'magical', it's a fantasy image anyways. Looks good and there is no major flaw anyways. The dog could maybe use a bit of that pointillism filter to blend it in with the guy and the background a bit better.

A good chop, very good mood and colors.

I think the light is coming from a whole in the ceiling =) nice work here.

Very atmospheric scene......I like the lighting I would say its pretty close, as there would be some indirect bouncing of light.

fantastic

very nice work author...i like strange lighting a lot....good luck to u

Nice lighting effect

Agree with the nice lighting, though why's the dog looking back? :P

love it!

Congrats for your second place, Genuine!

Congratulations, it's really genuine!

Congratulations, great lighting

thx all...for your comm....!!!

congrats!

Congratulations!!