I'm really liking these 3d Max thingies.. though how you have the patience is beyond me.. but I realize you have to practice before you can become adept at it.. good show and good luck author.. (Image is a tad dark, but I think that was your aim) good luck

nice work

I like the combination of 3D and 2D, it works really well, and this gives off a really nice mood. The only thing i would try to improve is the lamp.. it really doesn't seem like a light source, i'd take it back into photoshop and make it a ittle brighter. Good luck either way!

Yeah I would suggest the lamp needs some work also. Other than that I like the piece, good work.

cool.

OK, thanks, change the lamp, see new step 8.

very nice work

idea is nice, can have more finish