nice job... the musical notes need some work. they look a little to fuzzy.. it took me a moment to catch on what they were.. (Just a nit pick) over all image is quite nice .. Maybe make them black and a bit more glossy?.. just a suggestion and good luck

EDIT: Much better, I can really see the music now without squinting.. great job!!!

Not bad, but the base is blurry at bottom, and the drop shadow is totally wrong. Try to make a realistic shadow...

i like this image but the wood from the grammophone seems a bit blurry, if you want to make it more realistic try adding a shadow lin at the bottom of the eddges of the grammophone, and personally i wouldnt add so many music notes or make the grammophone smaller and let the musicnotes go up in the air

Nice, i think you should use some more burn/dodge and shadows.

very nice!

very very nice and creative fav so far

thanks for suggestion but ...if you look at the background picture you will see it is blurry at the bottom so I must to do gramophone blurry too ...the light came from bottom left corner so shadow supposed to be behind object...ok CMYK 46 I will do a realistic shadow but please explain me how

This is a really good idea but to me the gramophone looks too 'cut out'...maybe you intended that? Also, if you look at the shadows...they are very shallow whereas the curtain is quite a distance away...the shadow for the actual 'phone would be along the floor not a cut out behind...good luck!

very good work!

Glad to help with your shadow, author: http://www.photoshop-pack.com/details/Casting_Realistic_Shadows/11041

wow, great how you made3 this... it looks like real to me...

Kudos on the new shadow, author...looks great! (Base is still blurry, though...).

Oh, beautiful work! I'd really like to have this one in my living room Good luck!

great image! the notes are a nice touch!!

winner!!! congratz

very nice job and clever idea .. GL