no comments or suggestions? Is it that bad?

I don't think it's bad at all! I really like your idea and the way how you created it But maybe you can have another look at the shadow? It doesn't look right, but I can't really explain, why. Maybe it would look better, when you make it a bit more round? I'm not good at shadows, so I fear, that I'm no big help Good luck

try a reflection instead of a shadow... duplicate flip fade and line from the bottom and add a horizon line.. give it a little pazazz.. don't worry.. comments will come.. it just takes a little time at first good luck

the shadow is not good. you can't put a square shadow on a rounded object. it's not even positioned right. the rest is fine

very cool! and the shadow needs work

An old fashioned bath tub filled with bubbly.Very creative