You would have been better off making three entries than drastically altering this one twice.

That's one BRIGHT FROGGY. Not a bad thing, but in the photoshop world (because of all our photo altering toys) peeps like to see that kind of thing given some attention. (annoying I know, but whatchagonnado?) There are several ways to give him a little more "Solidity"... too many to mention all of them (HDR Filter/Darken High Pass/Duplicate Layer,desaturate,darken,fade blend, adjusting the filters to taste) you get the picture.
Making a reflection should be not that big of a problem for this one because you can see the ACTUAL reflections in the original Lily Pad picture. (Duplicate, Darken, Flip, place behind original frog, align etc...) Just don't over think it. That's always a disaster. Something I ALWAYS do...hehehe.
Great Idea for this contest, good job and good luck.

Making minor changes and corrections to an entry is permitted. Radically changing the entry is NOT! You have made more than one revised version of the original entry, this version is far too different to be considered having minor adjustments. You have used new sources and have created a totally different entry.

Members who have voted for the other versions may not have voted the same for this new entry making the previous votes irrelevant and void. For this reason the previous votes have been removed. Members will have to vote again for this entry.

DO NOT make another revised version or it will be removed. On future entries remember you are permitted minor adjustments to the original but DO NOT make a radically different entry with new sources as you have done with this entry.

Ouch author, to quote a very popular kid's movie (enjoyed by adults as well)
Shrek: All right, you're going the right way for a smacked bottom.
hehehe
Now don't do it again, or I'll go all "DONKEY" on your butt.
It is a whole new chop, and well done. Just be careful, as the Moderator so clearly pointed out.
I like the extra work as well. Good luck.