cool work...gl

Not bad, but edges of horse are too sharp & head needs a reflection.

You might consider cloning out the big rock at his feet and making it grass. A horse wouldn't stand like that on or that near a rock.

WOW! This is so pretty!

Thank you all for your comments!

Is it the same dog???

Author, you have two similar entries. Pick one. The other is obviously not anonymous.

very realistic work...best of luck

For a OOB effect, you have to remove the part of the frame that is crossing on the pathway.

thks friend for your comments, i have change it.

I think this would be more effective if the right edge of the photo weren't butting up to the edge of the image, i.e., like the photo's truly floating, unanchored to anything. Walking out of the photo into the void personally strikes me as more "alone" than walking towards a place with signs of human habitation [refine the title?]. The shadow needs to start from the footprints and go out from there. See the shadow in your source, and note that the shadow is especially strong right under the feet.

very nice...gl

Try to make the hand better...everything else looks pretty good.

Thanks .. I modified..

I think the hand is twisted! Try yourself to hold something that way... you will get a cramp!

very well done

great job author ! g l

Hey Good Job

Good.