Too much repetition.

author, this image is better if you dont repeat every thing

Ok guys Thanks Here is a remake any better?

nice in aspect of illusion

Not to big on the mirrored look.... frozen water needs little work, some light texture and where it meets the land.

The frozen water is missing the reflection of little wooden fence and two wood posts.

Thanks I went back looked at it If you look you'll see it's showing an upward reflection not so much right there on the ice I looked at it without the blur and the snow ?

snow on the statue looks blurred on high res

EDIT: better now

very cool (no pun intended)

Might be better to move the little guy so he's not crotch gazing...

LOL.. i'll fix that in the morning.

another awesome work.....! my fav, surely...

In the cold region like that, the shadow is not that strong because of the light reflection is everywhere

I had a feeling it was you author, great image.

You say true rufkut, I had the same.
The image looks fantastic. Best of Luck!author.

Like how you've kept the original colour of the statue as your theme colour and adapted the rest. Gives your image a real natural feel about it.

I never thought about that guy "crotch gazing", lol. I like the guy there, looks like he has come across an old civilization and is about to discover a whole lost city behind him. I like how you utilized the tree pollen and turned it in to snow here.

I agree with EmiK, you guys have bad thoughts...
Author, as always, one more fantastic work came out from your hands...

woah awesome...gud job author...

makes me think of the movie "the imaginarium of doctor parnassus" fantastic :p

Nobody ever tells you.....SBS please! Just wondering why?.....

Disco, my images (in my opinion) are usually self explanatory.. just blending sources and masking. If you take the time to look at the sources that i used individually, you can usually see what it is that i;ve done.

Thank you all for your comments and favourites!

OK. Thanks for the answer, but I thought they were obligatory? (pardon spelling if it's wrong!)

No not at all Disco.. SBS is preferred, but unless the source is totally unrecognisable an sbs is usually unnecessary. Most people prefer to see a step by step guide (i'm just lazy)

A SBS in a source contest is mandatory, when only the given source image was used (doesn't matter if it is unrecognisable or not). If external sources were used, it's not mandatory, but mods can always ask for one (in case there is something unclear). The author here used external sources, so a SBS is not needed.

Great job, author! You are really good in creating a mood and telling stories with your entries. But I told you that before
Good luck!

You asked for suggestions? I have one: Give up some of your talent to those of us who can't do this great of work! We would love you for it!
Excellent job with feel and mood here author.
(although I agree with CMYK about moving the subject just a little bit for the same reasons he gave)

Great entry author,I really like the colors

super

this work is verry verry verry over rated ... imho this work don't express anything ...like as many many many other works.... by this author!!!!...i don't want to offend anyone ... that is my opinion and i think i allowed to express that!!!!...btw author!!!...gl

Wow, I hope you are kidding there genuine2009. Because if you are not, you not only offended the author, but did so with malice and for no good reason.
I assume you have gone head to head with this author and probably got your ass kicked enough for you to say something like you did?

Of course you can express your opinion genuine2009. But anyone can do that. How about trying some constructive criticism. If you think this work doesn't express anything, then what would you change so that it does. It doesn't sound to me like you are here to help. Or maybe this site is just not on your level. There is a really nice site here http://www.cgsociety.org/. Good luck there.

LOL......i have my opinion about that...emiK....that is my opinion about author....and i don't change anything about that!!!...and btw emik....i don't need help!!! thx but no thx..enjoy your site!.. btw ...you are the author's lawyer?

Are all the 3D renders getting to your head Genuine? Relax.. i'm just having a good time here. Besides, if you ever need to voice your opinion contact me privately with something CONSTRUCTIVE. Simply saying my work is meaningless helps nobody, mainly because i won't stop entering contests because you get cranky.

Thanks Randy and thanks EmiK, your continuing support is very encouraging.

are you mad author?...ok....smile!!!! ... tomorrow will be worse!!!....you'll become an artist...great artist!!!....I forgot the quotes.....

cool..

LOL some comment Drama !!!! Great image SbS would have been nice. G/L

Do I dare comment after all these.......concept and image are good but IMHO the snow looks a bit ragged and off colour (gray) snow settles very evenly and builds very quickly, so I would expect to see more on the top of the hat, brim and creases. There is also IMO only a small amount of defused light in the scene most of what you see is reflected light from the environment so the shadows would be almost nonexistent.

Wow. great work author as usual. I would have made the little guy a silhouette of the big guy. Like he's looking at his past or something, but this is my favorite.

It's in the rules & guidelines, and fits for EVERY MEMBER:
3.2: Don't personally attack anyone. (no flaming or bashing)
3.4: Don't make negative comments without suggestions for improvement.
Let's enjoy this site...

very cool!... colors are great

Superb!

man, u rock

perfect! g l

Congrats for 3rd

congrats Matteo!

Congrats! Matteo! for 3rd place

Congrats for your third place, Matteo!

Congrats = )

ahahahahah i like it

the light source is different between mouse and cherry

wow, definately cool, just one little suggestion though, maybe a shadow under the copter would be cool you know, just to add a little more realism? also, cool baby choice

cute...

Very cute, it's pretty realistic!...

nice image..but it does need a couple things, including the shadow that Tuckinator suggested..but also a little more contrast and color..right now the copter is a little gray..just use the original toy as a guide and this image will look much more realistic..

Agrees with fatz, and also, you might wanna change the perspective of the ground, at the moment it´s off from the perpective of the chopper. IMO

i stink at shadows....heres an attempt

Cool realistic work

hmmmm......okay

Interesting concept...bottle is too small, glass leans to left.

Powerful. How ironic, we usually start drinking socially, but when over done we can easily end up all alone and lonely.

i try to fix the problems....!..thx CMYK!

right EmiK......

I don't like looking at naked men but this is a great job author!

> Poss, neither do I,....and I hate the man's nails too....
yeah,...great job