Wonderful, loved how you used the source to create the image. Good luck to you

Congrats...this is fabulous work

Good try, good luck. Probably a little more blending.

i think i would've used some more time chopping

lol..

Nice work! Well blended.. (are her legs supposed to be slightly transparent?) Good job overall!!

Great composition...nicely done!

I would have prefered a bit more colour for the bacgkround too, now it feels like it's completely black and white against her skin, even when it's not. You should remove the light transparency from the body/leg.. I wouldn't mind if the cape is a little bit transparent thou. If the spike reflections are actually shadows, you should check the orientation. Good work here..

Her legs are covered with some kind of white collants.... it's not transparent

pretty cool job

The blend is beautiful and the work too.....

Beautiful winter picture!

very cool ,nice ambient!

Interesting image with conflicting light sources, and a missing source link or two...

Haha, that talking seagull is too funny . Good luck!

I spent a lot of time on the lighting to get it the way I wanted it. Most light is coming out to right, but there would also be enough light still reflecting off glass to give light to the birds, etc around it. Really difficult to figure out, but guess each of us would do it a different way. Was still fun to do and a real learning experience. Hope I got all the sources finally.

If you want the lighthouse to be the light source, remove the shadow of the railing, which has an opposite light source...also please post source link for light house.

Thanks CMYK for your good advice.

Lookin' good!

nice one. good luck

great job