Interesting concept...gl

This is pretty cool, but it could be better. For ex. you don't need the dustbin in this context.

I agree it could be better - I'm still learning how

I thought the dustbin helped with the sizeing the city and cars...

Out side fo the bin, what would you do different?

Too much repetition.

author, this image is better if you dont repeat every thing

Ok guys Thanks Here is a remake any better?

nice in aspect of illusion

Not to big on the mirrored look.... frozen water needs little work, some light texture and where it meets the land.

The frozen water is missing the reflection of little wooden fence and two wood posts.

Thanks I went back looked at it If you look you'll see it's showing an upward reflection not so much right there on the ice I looked at it without the blur and the snow ?

different...

Interesting. But fruit bowl is distorted, fruit seem to be flat.

The flying apple has some mask work to do, you can see some extra there.. nice bubbles and room, but agree about the fruit bowl. It's flat and distorted, should fix it a bit.

This looks amazing. I'd love to see a full tutorial on this one. Looks like a lot of work but the end result is great!

Beautiful work, love the detail

not
not
not
not
but

Creative idea. Shouldn't the undersides of the tray and vases on the glass-topped foreground coffee table also be reflected in the water? Also, reflections are the same size as what they're reflecting. The desk-lamp and TV reflections shouldn't squish and the floor-lamp reflection should be more than 18 inches high, for example. [Put stuff on a mirror to see how reflections work.] BTW a dark floor is really needed to get a reflection.

Killer idea and superb execution, It really would look good with just a hint of a ripple in the water and a definite water mark on the furniture. Nice picture BTW

Amazing job author....very very well done...best of luck

Thanks everyone for the comments! This was a last minute decision to do. I didn't have as much time with it as I would've liked. I had to go to bed and now I have to go to work. Looks like I won't be able to edit this one before the contest deadline.

yeah shame you didn't have time. I think objects floating would have made it more realistic.

its a wow entry ........... all the best ..............

Looks like quite a bit of work, great job. Best of luck to you!!

Unfortunately I have experienced such situation when I was a child; it's so sad... Nice work, author! GL...

Good result! Good luck!

Congrats, a really detailed work well done

Congratulations for 1st

congrats for the 1st place ..............

congrats for the 1st ..............

Congrats!!

Congrats!

Congratulations! But I don't wish anyone this situation...

well executed... congrats...