Overall really nice source selection. Really like how you kept the part of the car in the reflection.

Very nice. But the snowman doesn't fit completely. I don't know exactly what it is. Or the shadows or it misses some motion (like the road)

very nice, well done!

Very nice image... I think the snow man looks good if you are looking at it while driving, but if the concept is to look in the mirror the snowman should be blurred. I think that is what Marcia saw looking back and forth from snowman to mirror to snowman.... You can't see 2 things clearly at the same time.. Great entry and g/l

Great idea, and well executed.. maybe suggest the sky on your background image with the one form the source, to help it look like it matches. And also if you look closely there's a slight blue color cast. I suggest opening the source image in photoshop and duplicating it, then going to Filter -> Blur -> Average. This gives you the overall colour of your image, then just copy that into your finished image and set the mode to colour or soft light and play around with the opacity. But like i said, great idea, and a very convincing image.

The snowman needs dome dynamic to create the moviment feeling. Nice work.

I agree about the snowman but my question is about the lanes....in the reflection it is just a two lane road...in the rest of the picture, it is like a highway with a median in the middle--so it kinda doesn't match

Thanks all for your comments and criticisms. I've added a blur to the snowman, changed the sky colour, and removed the other lane from the image outside of the mirror. (although I thought that it was a path and not a car lane). Anyways, I removed it just in case and to avoid confusion

you did a great job fixing stuff, but what happened to the snow on the trees---it's gone now?

Thanks K5683!!! I completely missed that one. I forgot to unhide my layers before saving the file.

Good idea....source fits in perfect

Congrats for your second place!

Congratulations for 2nd

congrats!!

Congrats!

Congrats!!

He looks awesome! Good job!

love it!

awesome good work author!!!

you should flip the right glove (from the viewer's point) because the light source appears to be under the glove

Needs some snow on the gloves, but good idea...

he looks really funny just like he want some hug ...."I hug you snowman!"

Okay. I listened to what you guys said. (thanks for the feedback btw) I decided to use the same ski glove twice, as the other one wasn't really in a very good position.

nice work, great idea

Congratulations for 3rd

Congrats for your third place!

Congrats!!

Congrats!

congrats

Congrats!

Not bad But the top of the rock needs to be seperated from the background.

LOL......beautiful blending........GL............

Good except for symmetrical tree duplication...

Smart idea. I like it but you could have made the trees in the background better. You want people to think: "How the hell did he do that.. ??"

real cool

cloning the trees would have produced a better result.

wow

that's really good!

Very nice, imaginative work. Good job!

Too dark...

good attempt

Reminds me of those old horror films. This isn't that bad actually. But CMYK is right, its a little to dark.

Was creepy when your first entered it.. is still creepy now.. LOL.. Great job as always

cool

good idea, but hand looks different, make it in the same snow style

scary

I think you need to make it clear that it's a mirror, try adding some reflection from the man or just play arouns with the blending options. Good luck!

^It's suppose to be a mirror that acts like a door, I'll change the misleading title

Btw, thx for all the comments

i'd delete the first paragraph of the description.. it's too much imo good image!

Reminds me of the movie "Mirrors"