this entry is actually accidentally the same idea of that "silent witness" !

Nice work...gl

beautiful entry ....... wish u high marks .........

Very romantic... GL, author!

Very good... Wine tasting time!

nice done

Damn...lots of wine can put in this cup...LOL...gl

Very effective usage of the source, I love it! Gl

Congrats for your second place, MjongE!

Congrats! for 2nd place and thanks for your all congrats.

well done and great capture of the feel.. this contest produced some great work.. and you should be happy.. hope you are

good idea.. just a couple of points.. the bottle is blurry at some edges.. so please sharpen it and since the 2 shadows pic is in a frame on the wall.. there should be a drop shadow so that it can follow the same light source as the wall.. I like how you got the napkins out of the paper boat..

Author, you have to remove the bread's reflexion of the backward glass... and they need more transparency.

Thanks so much for the comments . Always appreciated.

Similar entry already been made like this, a lot of the people are using the same ideas anyways like the towls on the hill outside dinning theme. I like how you made the napkins out of the paper boat It is a hard contest good luck.

wow.. this looks alot better.. thanks for taking my points.. but thanks to your rework this looks perfect..

Author, just great! You know I'm your fan...

the wine should be darker, the glass looks tilted and imo it looks like it's floating.. but good idea

nice idea i really like the bubbles inside the bottle but i think a better background would be welcomed

Nice attempt....

Not bad, but I agree about the background. Up to you if you'd like to change that. Good luck!

nice work

I like it!!!

good idea, but I would probably have made more of a reflection if you chose to keep your background to show that it was a reflective surface. Good Luck!

Good picture, would be more better if the source link worked and a High resolution was available

Yep, what lchappell said.

very elegant

Author, if you look at the candlesticks, there are no shadows for them (only under them, but very slightly). So, I think the shadows you put must be resumed on a pretty slight shadow under the source.
And yes, the link is broken...

sorry about the link..my first entry,i used no outside sources,the table i got it from artgirl1935,,from this site i just didnt know how to put it in the source

author, welcome to the site. if you need to mke edits to your contest entry, look to the top of page and drop the list down from the header "my stuff" look for my contest. there you will see how to change the information such as source links

that's very good

im sorry the source did not work....im new at this..this is te source http://www.pxleyes.com/picture/19334/4b9d8b6aa4d3b.html..since i dont know how to edit the original source...thanks to the moderator for explaining this to me..

Beautiful work.....Considering this your first entry, its really good...

try to ad shadows for the candle sticks.. . else is very nice... Gl

Beautiful work, but have to agree with others about the shadows on the candlesticks. Best of luck!

agrees about candle shadows. Better luck next time.

Congrats for your third place, Huero!

Congrats! for 3rd place