Great idea, but really look at the colors of the edges on the original pic...the edges of the tree form wouldn't be whitish. Also, the light source on the letter box in the source pic is opposite the one you've created. Look at the original shadows...

not sure if all the shadows match, but I like this, good use of source.

Thank you CMYK, pearlie. My weakness is working with shadows. I think, the letter box, looks ok (to me). Corrected the color for highlights on tree forms, making a little darker. Pearlie, I moved the shadow on the frame a little higher.

Really nice

Author, please look at the small box you've created. The shadows on the face are on the left. The light source you've created has opposite shadows...

CMYK is right about the shadows. Just try and adjust the shadows on the box going the other way. GL

Tweak on the shadows and this will be a killer entry

Thanks again guys: CMYK, I appreciate your suggestion about shadows on letter box. Sometimes I try to do things in a hurry, that I forget the minimum details. Learning from you all, good luck!

Excellent

Very nice image GL

lots of fun

very nice!

Better. GL!

Excellent idea and good job Author......G/L.

great job

Congrats on 2nd place george

Congrats for your second place, George!

Thanks, loopyluv, Lelaina...(CMYK for your wise advise)!

Thanks George...congrats!

Congrats

intersting but the young girlsis not realistic. try to change her face a bit

hysterical

Maybe give the younger, slimer girl a neck?

Very nice idea...good luck author

Funny. Why are they levitating?

I kind of thought the two should switch places, From left to right "before and after". Most diet ads are displayed that way.