2038 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar Deki
Deki says:

the shadow is oposite on the moon and the tower, but great work

(5 years and 3678 days ago)

Another Galaxy
avatar birdlady
birdlady says:

Well Done!

(5 years and 3678 days ago)

Another Galaxy
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

nice

(5 years and 3678 days ago)

Another Galaxy
avatar George55
George55 says:

Love the colors. Good luck

(5 years and 3678 days ago)

Another Galaxy
avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

Very dramatic, but the moon is very distracting in my opinion. I think that your image is really good, but the moon lets it down a tad. I'll hold my vote for a while

(5 years and 3678 days ago)

Another Galaxy
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Amazing...a moon just like ours in another galaxy...

(5 years and 3678 days ago)

Another Galaxy
avatar George55
George55 says:

Looks good... gl

(5 years and 3679 days ago)

The Old Factory
avatar ladybug
ladybug says:

congrats !! What a lovely entry!!

(5 years and 3679 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar birdlady
birdlady says:

Well Done!

(5 years and 3679 days ago)

The Old Factory
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

Congrats on your win

(5 years and 3679 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar Breno
Breno says:

Congrats, Akassa

(5 years and 3679 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Agrees with Hippunky, but still nice imagination.

(5 years and 3680 days ago)

The Old Factory
avatar loopyluv
loopyluv says:

Congrats!!!!

(5 years and 3680 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar Hippunky
Hippunky says:

Excellent chop - and far be it from me to comment (I'm a mere pleb!) - but might the tiniest amount of blur on the moutains help separate the factory from the background? [I'm prepared to be flamed!]

(5 years and 3680 days ago)

The Old Factory
avatar refleksi
refleksi says:

Congrat Akassa...

(5 years and 3681 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar nishagandhi

congrats

(5 years and 3681 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar Lelaina
Lelaina says:

Congrats for your second place, Akassa

(5 years and 3681 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar Giallo
Giallo says:

WOOOW!!

(5 years and 3681 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

nice job

(5 years and 3681 days ago)

The Old Factory
avatar ladybug
ladybug says:

Great work ! Very nice image!

(5 years and 3681 days ago)

The Old Factory
avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

Gee, i wonder who the author is!! Stunning visuals as usual

(5 years and 3681 days ago)

The Old Factory
no avatar

beautiful image.. surreal in a way. SO sad to have something so beautiful captured.

(5 years and 3682 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Beautiful image Poor horsie, don't want to be on its place...

(5 years and 3682 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Actually I prefer a story with an effed up ending (i.e. "Seven, Knowing, etc.) but mainly because those ending are NOT expected. Personally I think if you have to explain it, then it makes it hard to fit the theme. A good entry is an obvious entry.

(5 years and 3683 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

I like the image, and i like your choice of sources, but i don;t see how it fits with the theme, but then again i don;t really understand it :p Good luck, and high marks from me.

(5 years and 3683 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar albevolution

Great but to look more sucessed word you need to fix the blur in the end of bottle.

(5 years and 3683 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I don't get it, but the bottom of the bottle needs an edge...

(5 years and 3683 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar pixelkid
pixelkid says:

Nice blend...and cool final result!

(5 years and 3683 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar greymval
greymval says:

Nice one, but what's the story, why is it an end and not a beginning. Maybe the landscape that we can see through the bottle should be distorted somehow, maybe a spherize.

(5 years and 3683 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
avatar justin8787

Love it, everithink looks good, gl

(5 years and 3683 days ago)

Sad Ending Story
no avatar

great choices of stock. well put together. Hard topic, fantastically presented. well done author.

(5 years and 3683 days ago)

Dementia
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

nice

(5 years and 3685 days ago)

Dementia
avatar mariosilva

very good balance on a very strong image,congrats

(5 years and 3686 days ago)

Dementia
no avatar

One of these days I have to sit down and Learn how to do This.Beautiful Work of Art........VTD

(5 years and 3687 days ago)

Dementia
avatar GolemAura
GolemAura says:

WOW.. what an excellent job of matching the sources (I'm sure that was the hardest part) great Idea!!!

(5 years and 3689 days ago)

Dementia
avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

Nice idea, good luck!

(5 years and 3689 days ago)

Dementia
no avatar
RedBanana says:

looks good

(5 years and 3700 days ago)

Snowy Mountain
avatar jsk123
jsk123 says:

I agree with spaceranger. Nice image but not enough work with the source in my opinion. For some reason this type of nice image always wins tho.

(5 years and 3700 days ago)

The Storm Caller
avatar spaceranger

First I must say the image in general is quite nice. However as for use of the source all you seemed to use is the banana bench for her to stand on. She could be standing on anything there's no significant use of the source image, why is this lovely girl standing on a banana? As I said it's a nice image...it just doesn't relate well to the contest source IMO.

(5 years and 3701 days ago)

The Storm Caller
avatar pixelkid
pixelkid says:

Edits you've made have helped and this is a really nice image! Good advice all.

(5 years and 3701 days ago)

The Storm Caller
avatar sparklen
sparklen says:

Love the hair! Great image. GL

(5 years and 3701 days ago)

The Storm Caller
avatar woodztockr

Great composition!

(5 years and 3701 days ago)

The Storm Caller
avatar lchappell
lchappell says:

I like the reflections also

(5 years and 3702 days ago)

Snowy Mountain
avatar Lelaina
Lelaina says:

So they don't look like they could fall off every minute. I hope, that can help a little Good luck!

(5 years and 3702 days ago)

The Storm Caller
avatar Lelaina
Lelaina says:

The compostion is really lovely, just like the colours! But maybe you could try to lift the model a bit or give her her feet back, cause right now the proportions doesn't look right. Considering, that she's standing on the "banana" (she is suppose to stand there and the back of the dress is hanging over the "banana", right?) her legs are too short, at least IMO And maybe an idea to make the gloves look more like gloves: you could try to attach them closer to her arms, so they are directly on her arms without space between and widen on her hands (like they do now)...

(5 years and 3702 days ago)

The Storm Caller
avatar k5683
k5683 says:

I think the fins are too see-through and I'm thinking the sheet would be flowing a bit more--nice idea though

(5 years and 3703 days ago)

Hybrid
avatar Draco
Draco says:

Talking about fantasy, this chop reminds me of a dream of mine. I like the magic in the picture. Beautiful!

(5 years and 3703 days ago)

The Storm Caller
avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

Thos reflections look beautiful! Good luck!

(5 years and 3703 days ago)

Snowy Mountain
avatar LKY
LKY says:

scene creation is nice ....but I think shading part can be much better.........It luks like milk to me more than a snow .....anyways GL...

(5 years and 3703 days ago)

Snowy Mountain
avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

Very mystical and serene, in my opinion, the waterline in the horizon is a bit too harsh, try softening it with a lyer mask and a soft round brush. (just my opinion) Very detailed work, especially around her hands. Good luck!

(5 years and 3703 days ago)

The Storm Caller