Ummm...you may want to remove the American flag... Otherwise, this is good. Nice subtle humor, too.

Just blur the edges of the hands a bit and this will be great...good luck!

I agree with Havingfun, and the water coming from the hand could be less opaque...also there should be a highlight on the hand...

Good background, bad reflections at right...

The crack texture doesn't work on top of the cloth, but still a good image over all...

Not bad...sky looks kinda funny at right...

Yep, looks better now...good luck!

Try to fix the straight edges on the clouds...

Hands aren't from SXC...they're from Adobetutorialz.com

Interesting, but you lost a lot of detail in the eyes...

Not bad, but a bit too reliant on DA images...

Author, I remember this...if you haven't flattened your image, just find similar sources, and good luck!

Figure is pixelated, and edges of leaves on the legs should have definition instead of just being erased and translucent...

Good blend...

They look too flat...add more highlight & shadow...

Great to see this again...good luck!

Eye holes need more shadow...

Love the mood...

Lookin' good! Might be better with just one drop coming from the bottle IMHO...

Side of the house looks strange at this angle...you should hide it in the foliage...

Great mood and color, but the tree shadow doesn't work...

LOL...if you can't see the light source I don't know what to tell you....

Good idea, needs better & more consistent shadows...

Needs a high res version, but not bad...

Because as I said, the pieces shown add up to 2 dogs....

Ground perspective is off, but not bad...

Fix your source link and correct the shadows...
EDIT: Source is from blog. Please read http://www.pxleyes.com/blog/2009/06/how-and-where-to-find-legal-source-images/

Just make the pieces smaller...it ain't rocket surgery.

Nice stuff except for the shadows...they're too dark & too thin...

I love this, but there is only one way to consistently win at tic tac toe, and it ain't rocket surgery...surprising the aliens didn't know that.
Still, it's an excellent pic!

Author, IMHO the edges are crisp and well defined now, and work better with the light source...good luck!

Ummm...sorry author, but I see the same leaves as in the source pic, but green...

Some color to make the rose pop from the background will make this better...

Dead green leaves on the ground? You should have substituted grass...

Great idea, and well done...there wouldn't be art & type on the edges, though...

Great choice of sources, really good blend!

Great idea, masking & background not so good...you can improve this...good luck!

Cracks don't look anything like broken glass...

Try a displacement map on the arm...

Try a displacement map & high res version...

Cracks are much too large, but good idea...

Your technique is good, but if he's shaking off pieces of himself, why is he still there? There's like 3 times more pieces than actual dog...

What crap

Ummm...no.

It's "Fore"...and the golf ball should be flipped to match the light source...

Go to MY STUFF, MY CONTESTS, EDIT ENTRY.

You've made the background look flat, and the shadow needs to be rotated about 90 degrees clockwise to match the light source...

What font(s) were used here?

Eye is not from a font...