Not a bad idea, but the light source on the chef hat is opposite grandpa's light source...maybe you could flip it...and the drop shadow doesn't work, again it's opposite the light source, and there's nothing for the shadow to fall on anyway....
Oh, and sorry author, but I just don't believe you "drew" the chef's hat. It looks just like a photo...a low res photo at that.

This is really great, but source 5 is from a blog...I'm sure you can find a usable pic to replace it. This is way too good to be pulled...

Tasteful layout & use of fonts.

I might give the segments more highlights, but I like it...good luck!

Looks good, but soften the top edge of the glove...
(You'll have to explain the comments to me... )

Looks good except for all the artifacts along the edges...

Try to fix the making on the girl's hair. Lighting on girl is opposite lighting on man....

Would be better with a background...

I get the title, and your Brit boff on my "bloody neck"...good take on the double entendre. But what's the grey triangular thing at lower right?

Why not just post a decent SBS in the first place...? Some of us don't know how this stuff works. Actually, was any of this done in Photoshop? Maybe it should be in the 3D section.

Use smudge tool on the cat's fur, too...outline is too flat. With some tweaks this could be a great pic...good luck!

LOL...then I bet they had bloody necks then, too...

Tone it down to newsprint level color and it'll be more believable...

Looks good, but too many different fonts...

I'd remove the greenish cast, but the rest is good...

Here's an idea: fix the distortion.

He sure doesn't look unhappy...

Cherries don't work, they just distract from the lips...

Try to fit the image within the original mirror...

Good idea...try to fix white edges on painter...
EDIT: Looks great now, good luck!

Lips need texture too...

Nice job...I think the inside of the mouth would have more shadow...leaves are a good touch.

More original than most...nice job. (SBS might be good too...).

No.....

I like the color. The eye of the needle needs some work (bottom seems to be transparent) and the SBS is incomplete.

Not bad, but you haven't used the source except as a background.

Balloons again...yawn.
(Just to clarify, I gave you a good vote, but try to be more original).

Nicely done...

Fun pic...big grin here!

Light source on mill is from the left...

Reflections are bad...they wouldn't have reflections in rough water like that anyway...flames look a bit out of scale. Interesting idea, though.

Would be better without the upper shadows...

Bottom edge of gorilla's arm is a mess, and there would be some rubble from the mill, but it's an interesting idea...

Windmill blades are transparent...?

I don't get it, but the bottom of the bottle needs an edge...

Sorry, but you've got the background clouds showing through the rock...

Nice, but skirt is transparent...something needs to be under there...

What's being dulled down here? Seems off theme to me...

Author, I agree your pic isn't off theme, but it could have a better background IMHO...

Looks a lot better now...good luck! (Bring back your hi res pic!)

I think this is great! The only nitpick would be the man & pig kinda die against the background...

Why is the rock transparent?

Scale of girl is wrong, she should be smaller (or foreground hay bale bigger. For scale reference, the bales are at least as tall as the girl.) ...also note the hay bales would all be rolling downhill.

Yeah...I think grayscale makes it creepier for sure...

Crane is way too big...

IMHO water doesn't look natural, but it's not a bad image....

Blur some edges a bit, especially on shadows...maybe reduce shadow opacity a bit too. Interesting idea.

Bad idea...

Cool...a dog that can walk on water...

Interesting work...try to define where the posts enter the water...