9122 comments given:
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Looks better! It's hard to judge the light source in the background image, but I think the woman's shadow could be rotated about 10-20 degrees clockwise. See how it looks to you that way.

(5 years and 2352 days ago)

Shopping Time
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Just an idea...lose the wings & make the hair less green. Then the image would be more realistic. By flipping the head you have created conflicting light sources on the figure, so the shadow doesn't know where to go. Think about it...this could be a much better entry.

(5 years and 2353 days ago)

Shopping Time
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Might be better to center the woman's torso on the hourglass...this way she's just cut off.

(5 years and 2353 days ago)

Breathe by Anna Nalick
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

The full res image of the paper plane source is very sharp. It looks like you chose a lower res image, and now the edges are jagged. There's plenty of time to D/L the hi res pic & correct this, and as Waz said, fix the opacity on the legos. This could be a lot better!

(5 years and 2354 days ago)

Battle for the Trains
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

5.11. Use of Search Engines to Find Source Images: If you find images with google or yahoo image search, it doesn't mean they're not copyright, always check the source site to see if the image can be used or not. Wallpaper images are usually copyrighted.
Please take time to read http://www.pxleyes.com/guidelines/photoshop/
and http://www.pxleyes.com/blog/2009/06/how-and-where-to-find-legal-source-images/

(5 years and 2355 days ago)

entry removed...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

The top should be lightest. It's not. The front face with the Vader head should be darkest. It's not.

(5 years and 2355 days ago)

Entry number 85825
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, I like your image. IMHO it relies too much on 3D mesh. Still, you got a good vote.

(5 years and 2355 days ago)

Vader Boy in Tomorrowland
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, the example was just given to show how the values of the 3 sides would differ. The lighting is up to you. In your entry, the top would be lightest, and the front face (w/ Vader head) the darkest. The contrast doesn't need to be as dramatic as in the example, but it needs to be there.

(5 years and 2355 days ago)

Entry number 85825
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Agree with Spaceranger...well made, and creepy!

(5 years and 2356 days ago)

In The Library
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Please provide a functioning link.

(5 years and 2356 days ago)

In The Library
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Any cube that's normally lit will show 3 sides, as you have. Depending on the light source, each side would have a different value.

(5 years and 2356 days ago)

Entry number 85825
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Great use of source & color.

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

New Dawn.
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Congrats!

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

Flame On!
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Congrats, Rein!

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

A Walk in the Park
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Congrats!

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

Dionysus Plate
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Well done...Congrats!

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

Geronimo!
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Congrats!

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

Valhalla, I am coming!
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

How about a glow around the light saber, and a background for him to be standing on? And what's the reference image for the body?

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

entry removed...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

The drop shadow shouldn't appear on the background, and it needs to be blurred. The sides of the cube should have different values of shading unless you're implying it's lit from inside.

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

Entry number 85825
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

She's a babe!

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

Runway Robot
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

It looks like source 5 is fine. As for the others, you have plenty of time to find replacements and resubmit. Good luck!
(And read the photoshop rules & guidelines).

(5 years and 2357 days ago)

entry removed...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

This is a theme contest. It is only required to make a SBS if an entry is made from a contest source photo and no outside sources.

(5 years and 2358 days ago)

Earth
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, you need to post links to your sources.

(5 years and 2358 days ago)

Dangerous Beanstalk
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, it's a good try...find some useable images & resubmit. Check here: http://www.pxleyes.com/blog/2009/06/how-and-where-to-find-legal-source-images/
And please take time to read http://www.pxleyes.com/guidelines/photoshop/
Wallpapers & images from blogs are not usable sources.

(5 years and 2358 days ago)

entry removed...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Please post source links.

(5 years and 2358 days ago)

entry removed...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, the balloon is still completely flat with no shading. It needs to look spherical.

(5 years and 2359 days ago)

Entry number 85715
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

If the Martian hockey puck is in a position to reflect in the side of the building, it wouldn't be able to cast a shadow in the foreground.

(5 years and 2359 days ago)

You-Fo in Town
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Creative, but not sure it follows the contest description: " Try to make it look really creepy, but as realistic as possible."
Doesn't seem very realistic.

(5 years and 2359 days ago)

Entry number 85762
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I wonder where those old gods worked out? Odin's Gym?

(5 years and 2359 days ago)

Tríaina - God of Weapons
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I don't see them, and you've created conflicting light sources by flipping the cup at right. The light on the others is from the left.

(5 years and 2359 days ago)

Entry number 85771
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Not bad, try some shadows.

(5 years and 2359 days ago)

Entry number 85771
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Interesting idea, but the figures just blur into the background...they need to have some definition where they meet the horizontal plane, and some shadows. Also, try to give the planes some depth. The background planes should be darker, the foreground planes lighter.

(5 years and 2360 days ago)

golden life
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

No comments yet? Hmmm...this is a well made image except IMHO for the composition. GL author.

(5 years and 2360 days ago)

The True Girl on Fire
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I don't think I wanna be one of those guys...great image, author.

(5 years and 2360 days ago)

A Walk in the Park
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I love this guy! It's just that the snowflakes don't make it for me somehow. I think I might have given them a slight blur and a bit less opacity. Still, the main image is great.

(5 years and 2360 days ago)

Valhalla, I am coming!
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

The reflection shows things in the rear of the object. This is impossible.

(5 years and 2360 days ago)

14 floor telex
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Try giving the balloon some shading, and give the shadow a blur.

(5 years and 2360 days ago)

Entry number 85715
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I have no idea what the eagle is supposed to be doing in this image.

(5 years and 2360 days ago)

Not our war
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I wish you had left the background color a it was, and just added the blur.

(5 years and 2360 days ago)

Joy Ride
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good one!

(5 years and 2361 days ago)

Geronimo!
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good image. I'd like it even better if there was more color contrast between foreground & background.

(5 years and 2361 days ago)

The Gryphon Lives
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

The reflection is showing the top of the raft. This is impossible.

(5 years and 2361 days ago)

Entry number 85632
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Much better now. GL author.

(5 years and 2362 days ago)

Ares
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

(5 years and 2362 days ago)

Grand Canyon, UFO Sighting
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good work on the lantern. I didn't notice it in the source pic at first.

(5 years and 2362 days ago)

Treasure
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Please fix link 2 and the jagged edges at bottom of the foreground saucer.
Edit: Link works now.

(5 years and 2362 days ago)

Grand Canyon, UFO Sighting
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, you need to post links to the background & lantern.

(5 years and 2362 days ago)

Treasure
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Try making the cracked earth layer less opaque and/or on Overlay. That should give the face more definition.

(5 years and 2363 days ago)

Earth
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I'm not sure how this image complies with the contest description: " High resolution photos are mandatory in this contest, even in hi-res people should have a hard time determining if the photo is fake or not."

(5 years and 2363 days ago)

Exploring
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Way too dark. I'm not sure how this image complies with the contest description: " High resolution photos are mandatory in this contest, even in hi-res people should have a hard time determining if the photo is fake or not."

(5 years and 2363 days ago)

UFO Sighting!