9122 comments given:
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Jagged outlines on hands don't work.

(5 years and 3488 days ago)

finally peace
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Could use more texture, but very nice work.

(5 years and 3488 days ago)

the crab
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Seems like the head could move left just a bit, but good job.

(5 years and 3488 days ago)

Elvis
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Face looks flat after texture overlay...add highlights & shadows.

(5 years and 3488 days ago)

turning
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, the face in your source looks pretty good to me! Give it another shot.

(5 years and 3488 days ago)

Service with a smile!
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Looks more like Neil Young than Elvis. (Which is actually sort of appropriate, since Young is more of a rock god than Elvis ever was).

(5 years and 3488 days ago)

music god
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Thanks for the grins!

(5 years and 3488 days ago)

Jail House Rocker
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Lovely job...congrats!

(5 years and 3489 days ago)

Crane in Cattails
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Congrats, great job!

(5 years and 3489 days ago)

Time to leave the parade
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Interesting background, but the figure is distorted.

(5 years and 3489 days ago)

The beauty in passion forest
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Try to work on the hair...compare to source. There's something with the face, too...it looks distorted somehow.

(5 years and 3489 days ago)

Service with a smile!
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Love the mood & lighting...great concept, author!

(5 years and 3489 days ago)

What ya lookin at?
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Great job, but there are a lot of parts with jagged edges and/ or white edges that need blending and smoothing. Also, one of the tube things on the creature's back is in front of it's face, and they don't look convincingly attached to the body.

(5 years and 3489 days ago)

Crystal Guardian
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

What does this have to do with the contest theme?

(5 years and 3489 days ago)

GOOD GOES BAD
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I like the image but the SBS doesn't show how you made the grass, which isn't hanging over the edge of the bowl very realistically. And how were the ball things made?

(5 years and 3490 days ago)

Bonsai
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Blur or remove white line on shadow side of kid's head.

(5 years and 3490 days ago)

my dream
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

LOL...my other 2 cents? The glow works for me...

(5 years and 3490 days ago)

Heaven is a place...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Might be better if the rainbow didn't extend into the foreground, but good image.

(5 years and 3490 days ago)

Heaven is a place...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Foreground penguins are distorted...would be good to see a SBS to see how you made the ice effect, which is nicely done.

(5 years and 3490 days ago)

Made of ice
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Try to improve the masking on the fingers (use pen or lasso tool instead of magic wand) and post your source links.
Edit: Oops, sorry, I'm just used to seeing source links. Of course you didn't need any.

(5 years and 3490 days ago)

invisible player
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Interesting idea, but the background could use some work.

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

Quack Hat
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Light on building is from upper left, light on horse from upper right. Compositional elements are all on the left. Some rearranging would really help your image.

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

Amigo
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good sentiment, but the black of the hat & eagle dies against the black background.

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

semper Fi
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Yes, the ship should be farther away and smaller, but good idea.

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

Sinking Feeling
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good concept, but I have to echo Waz on the foreground figure. Nice job on the reflection.

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

Is this our future?
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Nice image. Would love to see what you can do without the liquify filter some day.

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

behind the aridness
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Nicely done!

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

Dryad
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Oh, now I see source 1 in the sky. Now I'm wondering why...

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

mary lake
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Much better pic now.

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

techno freak parade
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Wrong shadow, look at the angle of the shadows on the spectators. IMO there wouldn't even be a shadow of the plane at that angle....

(5 years and 3491 days ago)

War is over
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Very interesting image! SBS would make it even better.

(5 years and 3492 days ago)

PIRATE
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

WTF is with source one? The sailboat source (3) has a rough water wake but you've put it on a calm lake. IMO just better to remove it.

(5 years and 3492 days ago)

mary lake
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

No, you didn't. See the other reflections and how they're directly below the objects they reflect? The tower reflection needs to move to the right.

(5 years and 3492 days ago)

A day in the boat...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, this is not a good way to introduce us to your awesome photoshop talent.

(5 years and 3492 days ago)

dizzy..
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

PS: You really should make a SBS for this. Would definitely improve your vote.

(5 years and 3492 days ago)

Time to leave the parade
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Tower reflection is out of place (should be beneath original) but otherwise looks good.

(5 years and 3493 days ago)

A day in the boat...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

The inside edge of the boat nearest the dragon would be in shadow. Nice job making the boat from the source.

(5 years and 3493 days ago)

resting place
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good idea, but kinda flat. Try to create a more dimensional look.

(5 years and 3493 days ago)

Pencil Flower
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Did you add the vignette later? The image was too dark already. Try to create depth somehow.

(5 years and 3493 days ago)

techno freak parade
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Where are the train tracks?

(5 years and 3493 days ago)

"CraZy Train
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Where's the reduction and fragmentation of natural forms into abstract, often geometric structures?

(5 years and 3494 days ago)

Time Behold Flesh Behold Music
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I don't see Cubism here, just repetition of forms.

(5 years and 3494 days ago)

Time Behold Flesh Behold Music
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

All your source links are the same.

(5 years and 3494 days ago)

shaving  flagg
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Nice job...like the mood.

(5 years and 3494 days ago)

Storm on the Shore
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Looks good! Try to distort the far end of the bridge so it's smaller, and the perspective will be better. GL.

(5 years and 3494 days ago)

Time to leave the parade
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, Chalty had a good idea...it's not too late!
PS: The reflection would be foreshortened a bit.

(5 years and 3494 days ago)

Good day for a rocket launch
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Impressive work, great SBS!

(5 years and 3495 days ago)

Crane in Cattails
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good job making it look like she's actually in that field, but the image is pretty dark for such a theme.

(5 years and 3495 days ago)

Field Of Dreams
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Ripple the reflections...they wouldn't have sharp edges. Nice work other wise.

(5 years and 3495 days ago)

Magical night
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

ROFL...rocket suppository?

(5 years and 3496 days ago)

Into the Ozone