509 comments given:
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Overall nice idea and execution! I do think the thumb needs a little work though. Good luck!

(5 years and 3104 days ago)

Rock on
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Really nice color palette. Only suggestion would be a soft shadow under the giraffe. Good luck!

(5 years and 3111 days ago)

Gir-Have A Nice Day Tie Co.
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I understand what your trying to achieve, but only after you explained what it was in front of the alligator. With no high res image to look at the suitcase looks like a brick to me. Another suggestion would be to lower the color overlay you applied to the crock and let some of the natural color shine through.

(5 years and 3111 days ago)

In a while crocodile!
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nice job author! If it was me, I would have made just one. There are many good ones but my fav is lioness diaper company. Only suggestion on that would be to make the "diaper company" the same size as the box with lioness

(5 years and 3111 days ago)

Grouping
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Congrats on your first entry. Looks good and good luck

(5 years and 3112 days ago)

A
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Amazing job! Congrats!

(5 years and 3131 days ago)

Older
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Really Really Nice! Love how much depth this has.

(5 years and 3134 days ago)

Buried in the Sands of Time
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I really like the the look and mood of this. The rain is really smooth, but I'm disappointed with the resolution of high res.

(5 years and 3136 days ago)

God help us
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Overall nice effect! Only suggestion would be to clean up the repetitive cloning to give a more natural look. Good luck!

(5 years and 3136 days ago)

Ghostly Remains
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Really nice idea!

(5 years and 3170 days ago)

old bridge
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

As soon as I saw the sparks I thought this was you. Great work as usual, and I'm glad to see your work around again.

(5 years and 3180 days ago)

Daisy
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

LOL! I guessed that this was your entry. Great job.

(5 years and 3197 days ago)

Soup du Jour
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Everything is there! The shading, highlights, the splash the ripples the water on the floor the reflection in the water on the floor. I like you author, I really like you.

(5 years and 3202 days ago)

Tip It!
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nice idea! I must nitpick and way that there are some masking issues that must be addressed. The coat isn't fully painted on the right side, the hair is painted over the coat and the hat is painted over the hair. Fix those areas and I will stop nitpicking. Good luck!

Edit: Looks better!

(5 years and 3203 days ago)

Black City
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nice job of choosing the right sources for the coat and direction of the light. I noticed that you added eyes to the statue. Thats fine but the hat on the guy doesn't pass as anything other than a statue. You can probly get away with the skin, but I would suggest putting a real hat on him.

(5 years and 3203 days ago)

  	old  house
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nice idea author! You blended the head to the statue pretty well. Although the cloning of the base for the statue could still use some work. If you used the original bronze statue in the source picture instead of the extra statue it would've saved you the trouble of cloning the background and the original source would more noticeable. Good luck author.

(5 years and 3203 days ago)

white statue No:2
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Welcome to pxleyes! I'm kinda confused about what your trying to achieve with this photo. Is it supposed to be a statue of hitler? If so why hide the swastika right behind him. You could've used any other background in that case.

(5 years and 3203 days ago)

Hitlers MouStache
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Very intelligent use of source! There are a couple of nit picks to send this over the top though. I'm not sure what blur effect you used for the background, but would suggest a lens blur instead to add realism. Also I would try to add some noise to the spider and match it with the noise used with the lens blur. Really good idea, good luck!

(5 years and 3204 days ago)

The Spider
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

You've always been really good with lighting! I really enjoy all the details. I can tell you spend a lot of time scanning the image and adding all the necessary highlights and shadows to everything. Great job!

(5 years and 3204 days ago)

Grieve
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Congrats for first place!

(5 years and 3207 days ago)

Britney Spears
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Really nice movement! This is supposed to be a anonymous contest, you might want to remove your name from the bridge.

(5 years and 3212 days ago)

Escape
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I wish this would've placed higher, I really liked it.

(5 years and 3214 days ago)

"Big Fat Idiot" ~Al Franken
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

LOVE THIS!!!!!

(5 years and 3217 days ago)

Inferiority Renders to Merit
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

ooohhhh! Really nice, good luck!

(5 years and 3226 days ago)

Mega Man
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I notice you've grown fond of the displacement tool as have I. Really nicely executed, especially like the ball flying by at the top of the screen. Good luck!

(5 years and 3228 days ago)

Pongo In the Congo
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Really nicely done! On the fence about the bling stars on the ship though.

(5 years and 3230 days ago)

Playground Battle
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Yes! I think that looks much better, I like the details of the orb. Good luck!

(5 years and 3231 days ago)

Black Magic
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I understand what you were going for, but I would've went a different way. I would've left the water background and instead of using the liquify tool. Just copy the lips to a new layer and then just resize them proportionately. If you make them big enough she would look part fish. Regardless nice entry and good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Pucker Up, Valentine!
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Really nice! I like the details you've added, but would expect to see a cast shadow on the wall on the left side of the guy. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Finding my way home
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

What happened to the lights in step 6? I kinda preferred them, but maybe you had a reason for changing them. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

silence night
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I would've liked to see the whole arm and orb in focus, other than that really nice. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Black Magic
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I like the feel of this entry! Only suggestion would be to add the rain on a new blank layer and change the blend mode. It just seems really harsh right now. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

knights
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Right now this is good but has the potential to be great. Right now it looks like you upsized the head which is the main focus part of the image. The problem is that the face is now pixelized and the body is not. I would've tried to downsize the body not upsize the head. Also some more smudging and blurring with the hair could do wonders. I would suggest blurring the body just a smidgen to match the head now. Good luck author.

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Fathead
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Only problem I see is the color from the moon in the background overlaps the moon which is in the foreground. Fix that and I see no problems. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Just Once in a Very Blue Moon
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Would fit in well framed in a contemporary high rise apartment. Nice job, good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Degressive...to blue
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Harsh lighting from the top of the rider would create a strong shadow on ride. A little more work will make this look finished. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

valentino bee
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Since there is no apparent theme to this entry it would be nice to see a high resolution. That way we could see more details and judge on execution. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

space warp
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Really nice! I also had thought about making a creature from the chains, but after seeing this entry I think I'll pass. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Pet no. 13
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I really like this image! I couldn't really tell what was on the right side of her untill about the 5th look. Also not sure why you added an sbs with just one background image?

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Dear Edward
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I really like the overall mood of this. Only suggestion would be for brighter lights in the castle. Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Moonlight
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nicely done! Good luck!

(5 years and 3233 days ago)

Bakery Schmakery
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Thats the way to think outside the box!

(5 years and 3239 days ago)

Time For A Change
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Really nice idea! Only suggestion would be to add more depth to the image. The buildings are sharper than the source of players. Good luck!

(5 years and 3246 days ago)

Giants running back
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nice entry, only distraction is the dark spot on the bottom of the center pin. Lighten that up and this is great. Good luck!

(5 years and 3246 days ago)

cosmic bowling
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Interesting idea, I really like the force field. The only problem was that I really didn't notice it until I looked at your sbs. I'm not exactly sure why it gets lost in the image, the only thing I can think of is the smoke from her hands. Maybe if you made it into some type of electricity which also lit the globe? Regardless nice entry and good luck!

(5 years and 3246 days ago)

Angular Explosion
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nice entry! Only suggestion would be a harder edge on the leg and a shadow under the hat. Good luck!

(5 years and 3246 days ago)

"break" away from the norm
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Some sections look a bit smudged, but considering the amount of reconstructive work this took it's understandable. Really nicely done, good luck!

(5 years and 3246 days ago)

Barricade???? What barricade?
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nice feel overall! I would've liked to see more of the source incorporated in the final entry. Also the stripes on your landing would be vertical when it hit the edge. Good luck!

(5 years and 3246 days ago)

the promised land
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

I agree with CMYK on this one, I would like to see brighter lights (make a new layer fill it with black, set the blend mode to color dodge, use soft 5% opacity brush set to white or yellow to paint the lights). Also its rights legs perspective is a bit off. Overall nice entry, good luck!

(5 years and 3246 days ago)

scouts
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

Nice to see you again!

(5 years and 3251 days ago)

Chasing