1104 comments given:
avatar DanLundberg

One might argue that producing something awesome while limited by onerous contraints shows true creativity.

(5 years and 3556 days ago)

Hoax April 1! :)
avatar DanLundberg

Creative concept. An unsteady camera yields a bur, not a double exposure exposure as presented here, however. The jets by the UFO are the smallest so must be the farthest away, a distinction I would otherwise have expected to accord to the two center jets flying towards the left (in my mind returning back after having flown around the UFO).

(5 years and 3557 days ago)

Sunday Shocker
avatar DanLundberg

Cute. I personally think the big green glow and the white flare detract. The base flange needs more shadow to be consistent with the shadow on the globe.

(5 years and 3559 days ago)

It
avatar DanLundberg

Pretty cool! The bright UFO light above the alien should be creating highlights on the top surfaces of the alien (e.g., head and butt) with a corresponding shadow on the ground. I think a much brighter center for the light spot the alien is standing in would be much more dramatic. Also, I find the bright spot on the clouds in the center of the image distracting. (It would be interesting to experiment with moving the big-UFO/alien elements to the right a bit instead of being centered.)

(5 years and 3559 days ago)

Another Roswell
avatar DanLundberg

I like your UFO and it's in a dramatic setting. However, the water reflection doesn't match the vanishing point of the water itself. The huge UFO does not seem to be casting any shadow (light source for background seems to be high upper right). And I don't get the big cloud weirdly coming in to the center of the UFO. Also, the odd gradient border on the lower half is inexplicable and adds nothing to the image IMO. (Using the source image without correcting the slanted horizon/statue made positioning your UFO even more challenging.)

(5 years and 3561 days ago)

Lady Liberty Goes AWOL!
avatar DanLundberg

I like the golden colors. To me, the planet looks like it's in front of the temple. I would expect it to be beyond the temple which would be conveyed if the temple's spire overlapped the planet. Her reflection is off. It should not be like a shadow. It should be exactly the same size without distortion and go straight down under her. (Put a mirror on a table and stand a Barbie doll on it to see what I mean.) [If she were flying, this might feel more fairy-like. Or what if she were behind him which would convey more of a relationship between them consistent with the "lovers" title?]

(5 years and 3573 days ago)

lovers
avatar DanLundberg

Very cute with an appropriately fantastical fairy feel. The far hand seems weird, however (delete thumb and add finger?). Also, the wings seem to face a different direction than the boy is. I think a line connecting the wing tops should be parallel to his shoulders.

(5 years and 3573 days ago)

First Lessons
avatar DanLundberg

The blue skin is great, but I think the stripes are too dark. Striping on the Na'vi seemed subtler, not so obviously tiger-like -- it's Avatar, not Cats .

(5 years and 3573 days ago)

red hair avatar
avatar DanLundberg

Our moon is out in space beyond the clouds, not in front of them as you show here. Eliminate the glow around the moon and the clouds in the top half of the image, replacing them with a starry night sky. The possibility that one of those stars is ET's home makes for a more evocative image than these claustrophobic clouds.

(5 years and 3579 days ago)

Someone wants to go home...
avatar DanLundberg

Interesting concept, but I think the dome looks flat and the abdomen portion looks like a pasted-on picture. The leg portion looks only slightly less flat. Plus the vanishing point of the floor does not match the vanishing point of her 'test tube' [much lower horizon].

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

Model XYZ
avatar DanLundberg

I really like this now for its blatant recognition that it is yet another totally superficial sequel trying to cash in on the success of the original "American Pie" movie -- and thus a very strong contender for a Razzie! (Even though I myself misspelled 'raspberry' in my initial comment, I can't help but observe that 'cannot' is one word, 'Stifmeister' has one F, and 'apparently' has two A's. And I would say 'C-list actors.' Plus 'someone who' is viewed as more respectful of personhood than 'someone that.' [But I'm being overly pedantic. ] BTW no hyphen in 'Pie movies.')

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

No, not another one
avatar DanLundberg

This movie looks pretty awful! But the poster is compelling nevertheless. (Quibble: I think I would delete the "was" from the movie title.)

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

was silenced by a moth
avatar DanLundberg

Very cute, but a more cartoony background might be more effective. And maybe driving through snow would better explain the incomplete wheels.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Trip to the Beach
avatar DanLundberg

There's a cute idea here if you had left the car sand-colored and cropped the castle background so the car would be a bigger part of the final image.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Like Castle like Car
avatar DanLundberg

It's hard to argue that if this were a scene from a movie, it would not be eligible for a Golden Raspberry given how awful it looks, but for this contest I would prefer something witty and amusing that is a commentary on Hollywood commercialism.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

The Hero
avatar DanLundberg

Love the "Yet Another Pie Movie" concept, but "The Space Rocket" is lame, with the lameness accentuated by the unrealistic glass dome and rocket exhaust. (Certainly a movie as bad as this image would warrant a Rasberry Award, but I guess I would prefer the winner in this contest to be more clever over all.)

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

No, not another one
avatar DanLundberg

Depicting drought conditions is not the same as "an entry where water supposed to be the subject" per the contest's theme. And the shadows are a mess: the vulture on the carcass appears to have a shadow under it, to its right, and to its left -- is this a three-sun planet?

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Desolation (updated)
avatar DanLundberg

Cool skull in the smoke, but how is this "an entry where water supposed to be the subject" per the contest's theme?

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Desert fantasy scene (UPDT)
avatar DanLundberg

I don't think the animals stand out enough. And if they're not even at the beach yet, I don't get how this portrays the 'no water' theme of this contest.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Lost
avatar DanLundberg

Really like the concept. Can't appreciate the dead fish without a hi-res version. I think you erred in retaining the source2 sky when source1 has the strong horizon line I would expect as well as a sky that matches a bright background. Lens flare (which I'm not a fan of -- and didn't I see that in Avatar which is totally fake so why was that there when no real lens was involvled? [but I digress]) doesn't originate from the bright spot in the top right corner; the flare merely detracts IMO and should be eliminated as erathion (at least partially) suggests.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Out of water
avatar DanLundberg

Unique, interesting image. The front and rear (to a lesser extent) of the car seem bent towards the viewer [step 5 of SBS still looks flat; joint with center cab is the problem, I think] which makes for an unconvincing curvy car. Not sure about the blue glow, especially around the window. I think more difference between the wheel reflections would also be warranted. And the head- and tail-lights seem on top of the image, not part of the car (need a setting not unlike a gem on a ring).

(5 years and 3591 days ago)

Greece Lightening
avatar DanLundberg

Cute. But the road needs to be scrunched down significantly (probably roughly to the bottom of the tire rims) to make its vanishing point match that of the vehicle (which also needs to be matched by the crease in the vehicle's front bumper thingee). The shadow where the wheels touch the road needs to be much darker to eliminate the floating look (more evident in hi-res). The forward edges of tires are odd and don't seem to match the perspective of the car body.

(5 years and 3591 days ago)

SMS Car
avatar DanLundberg

I guess I get the [rather flat looking] snow-globe interior, but the splotchy hand and bubbly background seem odd.

(5 years and 3600 days ago)

Florida Snowman
avatar DanLundberg

I don't get any story here, but it would be surreal if the snow globe were realistic. MaXed is correct that the perspective of the base doesn't quite match that of the table (but I don't agree that the globe itself has to be perfectly circular).

(5 years and 3600 days ago)

trap door
avatar DanLundberg

Blurry and flat IMO. I think if the Teddy bear is supposed to be the focus, then it should be standing out more.

(5 years and 3600 days ago)

Old Softy
avatar DanLundberg

I think this could inspire a "Drag Queen" contest on this site.

(5 years and 3600 days ago)

super cop
avatar DanLundberg

VitalExpressions is right on IMO. I would add that the forehead pustule thingies don't seem to be embedded in his forehead, perhaps because they are more distinct than the rest of his face.

(5 years and 3600 days ago)

Hellferine
avatar DanLundberg

What good are brothers if you can't play with them as subjects? Lots of good ideas in the SBS, but the limits of Elements may have held you back, although using regular Photoshop would still have been a challenge. The cracks are a bit flat, not matching the contours of the face. You liquified features that warranted restructuring, but unfortunately the results look like liquification. The edge between the hair and the background is too hard (maybe an Elements limitation).

(5 years and 3600 days ago)

Demon
avatar DanLundberg

Creative idea (even if Oscar Wilde used the surname 'Gray' for Dorian, the American spelling of the British color 'grey'). But if I knew I had a portrait deteriorating in my attic on my behalf, I hope it would show that I was engaging in a lot more debauchery than this guy's worn half suggests.

(5 years and 3600 days ago)

Half Picture Of Dorian Grey?
avatar DanLundberg

I like the tatto selection, but I think the safety pin is too thick on the left side and does not blend with the tattoo in a way that makes it look like it's actually growing out of the tattoo.

(5 years and 3618 days ago)

ouch!! it hurts!!!
avatar DanLundberg

Creative idea replete with social commentary. This would look more realistic if the positioning of the base of the heel were consistent with the original glass-slipper image (use it as a model). Also, the shadows look like the shoe is floating rather than resting on a floor. I would just use the shadow in the glass-slipper image.

(5 years and 3618 days ago)

the cheapest high heel shoes
avatar DanLundberg

Creative idea and I like that's there's more to the image than just hair. I think there should be stronger shadows where the ice cream meets the skin and the wafer meets the ice cream. And shadows on and by the sprinkles would make them look more like they're on the ice cream, not floating above it. (I'm not sure about the sprinkles flying off the ice cream on the right side.) I wish the wafer looked like it were a rectangular, not a tapered, one. The stamp seems to be on the small side (at least by U.S. standards) and needs a cleaner edge and shadow.

(5 years and 3620 days ago)

Icecream Hair
avatar DanLundberg

Amusing. Raise bottom of frame to make clear front of train sticks out far enough for smoke to be in front of frame. I think this would work better if the protuding tracks seemed three-dimensional (add left side to left track, terminate tracks with the cross-section you would see if you cut through them). And maybe eliminate the protruding gravel. Also, the protusion's shadow doesn't make sense, especially if the tracks are jutting out towards the viewer.

(5 years and 3627 days ago)

stop the train
avatar DanLundberg

Cute. A small, darker shadow at the base of the cabins might make them look more like they're sitting in the sand rather than floating above the two-dimensional background plane.

(5 years and 3629 days ago)

Beach cabins
avatar DanLundberg

Very appealing with a very informative SBS. Is the big blank space where one would write a personal message? I think this would be an even stronger entry if you were to write in your own non-trite, heartfelt message that matched the charm of the card you've created here.

(5 years and 3657 days ago)

Chrimbo Cardboard
avatar DanLundberg

I think separate gradients for each line of text so each letter essentially goes from white to gray would be more dramatic and less curious.

(5 years and 3658 days ago)

Merry Christmas
avatar DanLundberg

Interesting, but perhaps a bit too somber. The font choice looks great on "Christmas," but the "Merry" is difficult to decipher without the "Christmas" clue that follows it.

(5 years and 3658 days ago)

merry christmas
avatar DanLundberg

There's a lot to like here, but I'm not sure it comes together as a whole. The problem may be the ribbon which is neither a drawing [like the rest of the image] nor realistic. The knot should have edges, the interior of the loops should be darker, and the ribbon should cast more realistic shadows.

(5 years and 3659 days ago)

merry christmas
avatar DanLundberg

Christmas does not lend itself to a lot of originality in textual messages. Why one line is white while the next is gray is more curious. I really like the image but am concerned that the left side of the top three garlands don't wrap tightly to the tree shape. I also think a brighter star that doesn't blend into the tree shape would be more dramatic.

(5 years and 3659 days ago)

Merry Christmas
avatar DanLundberg

Very cute. Not sure I like the reflections, which don't properly match what they're reflecting in any event (should be same shape and size). I would be curiouse to see the "screenshot of how your logo design looks on the site" as on first blush it would appear that the Santa hat would extend off the screen and the left side of the puddle would extend beyond the tilted white background shape.

(5 years and 3667 days ago)

Red Pxl
avatar DanLundberg

...but I'm not sure it meets the contest requirement to create realistic-looking origami "out of other images."

(5 years and 3701 days ago)

Pegasus
avatar DanLundberg

I think more visual clues of ginormity such as a sailor and trees would add clarity and drama. Also, the reflection in the water should be the same size as the original, not squished.

(5 years and 3701 days ago)

Fee-Fi-Fo-Female
avatar DanLundberg

Cute. The black-and-white pattern especially looks flat. It needs some spherizing to make it appear like it wraps around each of the clogs.

(5 years and 3779 days ago)

clogs shop
avatar DanLundberg

I used to have hair, too, but I digress. The brightness of the skin tones is a tad off. The interaction between the two is confusing and in any event not sufficient to declare 'couple.'

(5 years and 3794 days ago)

Jimbolina
avatar DanLundberg

Some very cool elements like the sub itself. The lack of any portholes is a but disconcerting, however. The three miniature smoke stacks (with rather modest smoke output) seem inconsequential compared to the odd inhaler horn on the front of the sub [which I would personally delete]. I wish the front and back propeller blurs were more rotational.

(5 years and 3794 days ago)

Flying Steam Sub
avatar DanLundberg

Very awesome overall! The shadows on the upright plate on the top shelf make it look more like a ring with a rotating disk inside it. The balls on the bottom plate [where did the gray come from?] look like they're floating (and I think painting those pure accessories in the cow design--except for the brown front [which I like otherwise] of the front ball for some reason--might be too much). I admit I'm not real fond of the blue drapery background which seems too formal with folk art, but that's probably very minor point.

(5 years and 3794 days ago)

Souvenirs In Blue
avatar DanLundberg

Very creative and then very resourceful to find a celebrity with views from lots of different angles.

(5 years and 3795 days ago)

Yoda Kelly split!!!!
avatar DanLundberg

The beefy hand does look a bit big for a little dude like Justin Long, but otherwise this is quite realistic -- and doesn't glove size indicate....

(5 years and 3795 days ago)

Olivia Wilde and Justin Long
avatar DanLundberg

Interesting. The near side of the front lenses is thin, yet the far side seems to be very thick. Shouldn't a fourth supporting rod be visible on the far side as we look through the front lenses? Also, the view through the near front lens doesn't seem to be quite the right color to be the background. (You got lucky with the far front lens.)

(5 years and 3796 days ago)

I C U ...
avatar DanLundberg

Amusing, but I'm not sure that posing with your chin over somebody's shoulder, even with an odd mini product placement in the corner, makes you really a couple as commonly understood. Rainbow background is good. Mr. Kristol's arm reaching around to Mr. Rush's chest would seal the deal.

(5 years and 3798 days ago)

Kristol RUSH