80 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Sorry, didn't look closely enough. GL author.

(5 years and 2545 days ago)

We are under attack
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Ouch! That lens flare hurts! Otherwise not a bad image. What's the source for the figures on top of the cliff?

(5 years and 2545 days ago)

We are under attack
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Very very nice piece of work...best of luck author

(5 years and 3212 days ago)

Lovers in Japan/Reign of Love
avatar bddesign
bddesign says:

i think its fine dark... its night time with no lights really... its supposed to be dark. i wouldnt lighten it up any more... if you must go that route in one way or another, instead bring out more details at the focal points to make them more pronounced, and bring in a little more detail in the darker parts to keep it balanced.

(5 years and 3212 days ago)

Lovers in Japan/Reign of Love
avatar arca
arca says:

Lovely image and great concept ... I agree it is a little dark but only a little ... I have seen a night sky where the stars stand out against a "void" when there is something that you cannot quite make out in front of them. I think a little lightening and some minor toning down of the sparkles would enhance the image .

To lighten you can apply a Levels adjustment layer and brighten it up so the image is "too" light ... then mask out what you don't want to lighten and set opacity to get it just right ...that is if you want to

EDIT: Better!

(5 years and 3213 days ago)

Lovers in Japan/Reign of Love
no avatar
Keiley22 says:

The idea is good, however the image is very dark. Its almost like the saturation and contrast are making this image darker.
With the couple in the foreground, if you took a bit of the sparkles around them off, then they would be a little bit more clearer as well, the you may not need to lighten the image too much more

Goodluck anyway author

(5 years and 3213 days ago)

Lovers in Japan/Reign of Love
avatar apocalips
apocalips says:

coldplay 4ever good job

(5 years and 3213 days ago)

Lovers in Japan/Reign of Love
avatar Se7eN0f9
Se7eN0f9 says:

instead of give the author such negative comment, you could give some advice to improve the image mossyb, maybe its just someone how just get started with ps and then u need some build up comments and not that kind ur give

(5 years and 3214 days ago)

Lovers in Japan/Reign of Love
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Too dark. Half of your image is so dark, it's very hard to see what is going on, or what you are trying to communicate. Particularly the RH side. The building looks like a facade, with no real back to it, the stars seem to jam right up against the lit front, with the remaining blackness on the right just "dead space."
The figures are almost impossible to make out as a couple, the light swirl is too dominant.

Beautiful concept, just too "moody," with not enough consistent illumination for the viewer to clearly appreciate your efforts.

(5 years and 3214 days ago)

Lovers in Japan/Reign of Love
avatar gopankarichal

...............................ok

(5 years and 3343 days ago)

Day
avatar Nays
Nays says:

I like this kind of work a lot. Maybe something more can be happening in the dark part of the image, it is night after all and then the most creepy things can appear...

(5 years and 3344 days ago)

Day
avatar Concrete
Concrete says:

nice light effects

(5 years and 3344 days ago)

Just say yes
no avatar
Keiley22 says:

No images, nothing as decoration and no textures; in other words no outside sources are allowed.
You can not use stamps or brushes etc etc, only words are allowed to be used. Please go back and read the contest description

(5 years and 3348 days ago)

Just say yes
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

You should put a person on the opposite side of the stairs in the night part...
Excellent and very creative idea you've done here!

(5 years and 3348 days ago)

Day
avatar sunzet
sunzet says:

Nice glowing, but the sparkles are a brush? You could do them as small letters instead, would really keep the theme right on. Realize it might be a enormus job to change, but I recommend it. Feeling the rythm though

(5 years and 3348 days ago)

Just say yes
avatar Gransbergis

too blury, and i agree with vladimir735

(5 years and 3355 days ago)

Jump (for joy)
avatar erathion
erathion says:

nice work author...good luck

(5 years and 3356 days ago)

Jump (for joy)
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The text is too close to the girl, and gets a bit lost in the light effect.

(5 years and 3356 days ago)

Jump (for joy)
avatar vladimir735

Very nice! You might wanna make the girl cutout a little better, since it's gonna be easy with the blue background. Good Luck !!

(5 years and 3356 days ago)

Jump (for joy)
avatar arca
arca says:

Lovely concept ... a wee suggestion that I think would help; have the waterfalls thin out at the bottom so they don't end as abruptly ... that would give the whole image a more realistic look. A tiny bit of clean up on the tail of the foreground bird.

Great image though really like the whole feel of it!

(5 years and 3365 days ago)

High Above
avatar MnMCarta
MnMCarta says:

OMG This reminds me of thos floating mountains in Avatar! Great job!

(5 years and 3365 days ago)

High Above
avatar Kid
Kid says:

I like the ants crawling at the top gl

(5 years and 3454 days ago)

Horror Book
no avatar
Keiley22 says:

have to agree, if you look at the texture of the book and the aged look and then look at the skull and hand.... the skull and hand look rather neat, new and very smooth... hope that makes sense I do like your idea though author so will hold my vote

(5 years and 3456 days ago)

Horror Book
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

IMO, I'd like printing of the cover had more grungy, oldish like the cover itself. It's quite vivid...

(5 years and 3456 days ago)

Horror Book
avatar itsdesign
itsdesign says:

good luck

(5 years and 3496 days ago)

The end?
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

GL

(5 years and 3497 days ago)

The end?
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

GL

(5 years and 3497 days ago)

Flying Apple
avatar itsdesign
itsdesign says:

good luck

(5 years and 3497 days ago)

Flying Apple
avatar hereisanoop

very nice... and coooooooll...... no no... HOT...

(5 years and 3501 days ago)

The end?
avatar Chalty669
Chalty669 says:

A little masking issue under the closest kajak. Other than that nice details.

(5 years and 3502 days ago)

The end?
avatar swordfish
swordfish says:

Rest In Piece .......... or in ...........Peace........... peace ...........peace ..........
gud entry and all the best to u ...........

(5 years and 3503 days ago)

The end?
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

What Dan said...might be better with a background, too.

(5 years and 3504 days ago)

Flying Apple
avatar swordfish
swordfish says:

nice entry......... all the best to u .............

(5 years and 3504 days ago)

Flying Apple
avatar RAZ0R
RAZ0R [banned] says:

(5 years and 3504 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar DanLundberg

If the front of the applecoptor is 6 o'clock, I would expect the tail to be at 12 o'clock, but instead it's at 10 o'clock. In hi-res, you can see a light-colored outline around the rotor and landing strut that ideally should be removed.

(5 years and 3504 days ago)

Flying Apple
avatar Drivenslush

this is really great author.. but it really needs an SBS so we can see how you made it (especially to make it into a Tutorial.. it would be awesome) this also gives you higher votes..

Lovely image all round and right on theme!!!

(maybe a nice airport background to complete the scene.. it really does deserve it.. ) hehehe.. good luck

(5 years and 3504 days ago)

Flying Apple
avatar hereisanoop

like to have one

(5 years and 3504 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar itsdesign
itsdesign says:

nice idea

(5 years and 3504 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar Drivenslush

very clever Idea author... good luck

(5 years and 3506 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar swordfish
swordfish says:

nice idea .............

(5 years and 3508 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar swordfish
swordfish says:

nice image......... all the best..........

(5 years and 3510 days ago)

She
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

GL

(5 years and 3510 days ago)

She
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

That's a hot idea! Er... cold idea...
But I agree with iquraishi and lvstealth about the drip shadow; about the stick, you can add a shadow casting from the finger (or mask the finger behind the stick, with a shadow from the stick - whatever...)

(5 years and 3510 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar lvstealth
lvstealth says:

the ice cream (my favorite thing besides hockey!!) seems to be to the front of the hand (the drips and palm show it) but the stick is behind the fingers, it doesnt seem quite right. agree about the drip. the light seems to be from the top left for the hand and the right for the ice cream. good luck author! i love ice cream!

(5 years and 3511 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar iquraishi
iquraishi says:

u just need to add some shadow where the icecream is melting and spreading on the hand..

(5 years and 3511 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar iquraishi
iquraishi says:

yes.. its a great idea and also a very YUMMY one.. hhhmmm..

(5 years and 3511 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar lchappell
lchappell says:

No... great idea!

(5 years and 3511 days ago)

Bad idea...
avatar itsdesign
itsdesign says:

good luck

(5 years and 3511 days ago)

She
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Is there a source for the shadow? You'll have to make an SBS (step by step) if you didn't use any other sources. Mods will remove it if you don't.

FYI: just trying to be helpful.

(5 years and 3513 days ago)

She
avatar Geexman
Geexman says:

nice but I would have definatly given it the full droste effect, good luck

(5 years and 3524 days ago)

renovated