457 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Please post your source link, and read http://www.pxleyes.com/guidelines/photoshop/

(5 years and 1354 days ago)

Time to work
avatar kyricom
kyricom says:

I like the country road and composition.

(5 years and 1357 days ago)

Bee nice
avatar Drivenslush

Author, in your SBS make a note that it is YOUR PHOTO. (silly nit pic, but better safe than sorry. Very important. (Very good job, love how you bent the perspective on the original photo to match the angle of the face. Warp could help with fine tuning.)

(5 years and 1358 days ago)

Lady justice blindfolded no more
avatar Drivenslush

Spank Spank Spank

(5 years and 1358 days ago)

The Wizard
avatar Drivenslush

"Harvey 2.0". Replacing James Stewart with an ingenue. hehehe

(5 years and 1358 days ago)

Nightmare during Daylight
avatar Drivenslush

Brilliant usage of your own photos author. BRAVO!!! wonderful imagination. Though I could have done without the shaking of the camera (I had to leave the theatre during Cloverfield, the found footage made me yarpy) JUST KIDDING. Wonderful Creation.

(5 years and 1358 days ago)

The Wizard
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good idea. Reminds me of Donny Darko.

(5 years and 1358 days ago)

Nightmare during Daylight
avatar lolu
lolu says:

Congrats !

(5 years and 1362 days ago)

Time flies
avatar George55
George55 says:

Congratulations....

(5 years and 1364 days ago)

Time flies
avatar nilknarfsoive

Congrats!!!

(5 years and 1364 days ago)

Time flies
avatar Drivenslush

Great job... Congrats!

(5 years and 1364 days ago)

Time flies
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!! Definitely worthy of a higher score IMHO.

(5 years and 1364 days ago)

Time flies
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

Nice work

(5 years and 1364 days ago)

Moisture on a feather
avatar MsgtBob
MsgtBob says:

Great shot!

(5 years and 1364 days ago)

Moisture on a feather
avatar BeSea
BeSea says:

Entries can only be replaced during the days that the entries are open for submissions, before the "vote only" begins. After that, your entry is locked in and no further changes can be made, unfortunately.

(5 years and 1365 days ago)

Glasses
avatar BeSea
BeSea says:

I like the detail in the glasses a lot, but I think that cropping out the distractions on the top and left side would have improved the composition. IMHO

(5 years and 1366 days ago)

Glasses
avatar Mambo5
Mambo5 says:

ToO fun!!

(5 years and 1367 days ago)

The colorful chessbox
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Or select the area outside the hand, contract 1 pixel, feather 1 pixel & delete. Either way the entry will improve.

(5 years and 1368 days ago)

Time slipping away
avatar oziipop
oziipop says:

This is really cool!
I agree with CMYK46. IMO the drop shadow tool will diminish a great pic. Paint your shadows..you will have more control of where they lie and look more natural. For the hard hand edge, just make a second hand layer, Gaussian blur bottom layer, (about 30%). then take your eraser (50%) and erase only bits of the edges creating foreshortening. Same with table edge. I love Dali btw

(5 years and 1368 days ago)

Time slipping away
avatar George55
George55 says:

Nice job... congratulations for 4th...

(5 years and 1371 days ago)

Sky is limit
avatar kyricom
kyricom says:

Nice. maybe a little closer crop?

(5 years and 1371 days ago)

Orange Butterfly
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

That's really thinking inside the box!

(5 years and 1371 days ago)

The colorful chessbox
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

They might have read the goal, not just the title;
Stairs lead us up, down and, in some cases, nowhere. They are the subject of hit songs (hence the title). Your challenge is to take a photo of stairs. They can be inside, outside, part of a building or house, alone and freestanding, occupied or unoccupied. Think of creative angles and try some interesting lighting to create an image that is less than ordinary. Just take that first step...

(5 years and 1372 days ago)

heaven improved the way up
avatar Drivenslush

Super cool author, and excellent SBS. I would suggest to replace the Pawn in the Hand Picture with the Pawn from the contest source. (Not necessary, but it would add to the the synchronicity of the image, making all the pieces alike). GREAT JOB!

(5 years and 1372 days ago)

The colorful chessbox
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

looks like a jetty, not stairs?

(5 years and 1372 days ago)

heaven improved the way up
no avatar
RayTrain says:

time fly's when your making art great job

(5 years and 1377 days ago)

Time flies
no avatar
RayTrain says:

liquid metal Thats nice

(5 years and 1377 days ago)

Time slipping away
avatar Drivenslush

Awesome concept author! Liquify works great to create the melt effect, you can also copy the bottom part of the watch of the melted section (copy) and perspective it so that it looks like it's moving toward you and on the surface of the wood instead of just touching the surface. Tricky, but it adds to the effect. Not necessary just a suggestion. Good luck.

(5 years and 1377 days ago)

Time slipping away
avatar patty
patty says:

Congrats on 1st, well deserved

(5 years and 1378 days ago)

Lovers Lane
avatar madamemonty

Congrats Fred

(5 years and 1378 days ago)

Lovers Lane
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

Congratulations on 1st place, and the other god placings this week. Well done.

(5 years and 1378 days ago)

Lovers Lane
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Light source on the hand is from upper right. Shadows should be cast accordingly. You might want to soften (feather or blur) the hard edges of the hand, too.

(5 years and 1378 days ago)

Time slipping away
avatar BeSea
BeSea says:

This is a wonderful night shot, but not really showing a lot of dark for the subject at hand.

(5 years and 1378 days ago)

Bridge by night
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

well done

(5 years and 1381 days ago)

Old venetian mask vs plastic
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

You might want to soften (feather) your edges, otherwise good entry & SBS.

(5 years and 1381 days ago)

Time flies
avatar BeSea
BeSea says:

The DOF propels your eye towards the couple. It gives this, well.....depth.

(5 years and 1382 days ago)

Lovers Lane
avatar WYSIWYG
WYSIWYG says:

Wonderful colours!

(5 years and 1382 days ago)

Bridge by night
avatar George55
George55 says:

By looking at your SBS, I got the idea how your image was made. You did a lot of work putting things together. Nice image. Good luck.

(5 years and 1382 days ago)

Sky is limit
avatar Drivenslush

Super fun image... you know author, the ship could be even larger. Only if you want too. I just love all the details (the strings are marvelous).
As a print, the design is fine, but if you enlarged the Ship/vehicle it would be much easier to see. Then again my eye sight is kind of wonky,hehehe.. great job. Lovely use of your own photos

(5 years and 1383 days ago)

Sky is limit
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Sorry author, I only noticed no source links posted & didn't look at the SBS. My apology.

(5 years and 1383 days ago)

Sky is limit
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Please post your source links, and read http://www.pxleyes.com/guidelines/photoshop/
EDIT: Author posted own source pics.

(5 years and 1383 days ago)

Sky is limit
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

Congratulations on 1st place, a beautiful photo.

(5 years and 1385 days ago)

Morning Glory
avatar kyricom
kyricom says:

I like the windmills in the background

(5 years and 1385 days ago)

avatar WYSIWYG
WYSIWYG says:

Wonderful

(5 years and 1386 days ago)

avatar George55
George55 says:

It was a good combination of your drawing with the texture. Good luck.

(5 years and 1387 days ago)

Dragon sleeps
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

The high res is interesting.

(5 years and 1389 days ago)

avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

beautiful

(5 years and 1390 days ago)

End of the world
avatar roon
roon says:

wonderful photo , cut a little from up and down sides and its ok.

(5 years and 1390 days ago)

Morning Glory
avatar roon
roon says:

another nice photo not 1:5

(5 years and 1391 days ago)

Morning Glory
avatar Drivenslush

No problem author, now center his horn or give him two for balance, it's annoying... I AM JUST KIDDING, it's fine just the way it is, I'm just messing with you. It reminds me of the "Cartoon Films" on PBS on late night that were "not allowed" in prime time way back in the 80's. Mainly because they were just a little off base college creations that involved Frankstien Chocolate Cake that the villagers had to eat in order to kill it. Weird. Thanks for the memory dump LOL

(5 years and 1391 days ago)

Dragon sleeps