826 comments given:
avatar RayTedwell

I like the idea, just a little too dark for me

(5 years and 3698 days ago)

Eclipse Lighting
avatar RayTedwell

you need to put the shadow layer under the insect!

(5 years and 3698 days ago)

grasshopper
avatar RayTedwell

Wow, that must have taken ages! Looks awesome.

(5 years and 3698 days ago)

absorbing green
avatar RayTedwell

I really like it, GL

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

Futuristic Wanted
avatar RayTedwell

nice thought in this one

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

Personal Scanners
avatar RayTedwell

Really like this, the placement of the wings bothers me a little though - just a bit high.

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

Fairy Dust
avatar RayTedwell

A couple of areas for improvement as mentioned, but a great image and nicely framed by the trees too. Good job!

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

steam punk fairy
avatar RayTedwell

What it lacks in sharpness it makes up in mood - nice piece.

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

Fairy in the Lotus Pond
avatar RayTedwell

Nice job

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

Napping Fairy
avatar RayTedwell

There are a lot of elements but it all seenms to work really well - beautiful!

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

Learning new Tricks
avatar RayTedwell

So many points for originality, nice execution too

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

Retired
avatar RayTedwell

So many fairy snobs here, telling you what colour the imaginary creature should be!! I like the image, except the flower in her hair is a bit much. GL

(5 years and 3699 days ago)

Fairy Night
avatar RayTedwell

Author, technically I think you are correct, but it isnt really in the spirit of the contest. I think this is a beautiful image, but the contect isnt called 'edge of plate'

(5 years and 3700 days ago)

in flight
avatar RayTedwell

nice job with the shadows, I'll give you my vote now (not that it counts for much) :P

(5 years and 3702 days ago)

Cow Tipping
avatar RayTedwell

Ive seen this pun used before, but a fun idea and well chopped. The blur on the background is nice

(5 years and 3702 days ago)

Navy Seal
avatar RayTedwell

just a quick tip, to make things look more realistic, pay close attention to the light source. Try rotating the objects around and see how it affects the image

(5 years and 3702 days ago)

Dinner
avatar RayTedwell

I do find it hard to believe she'd still be smiling

(5 years and 3704 days ago)

tooth&nail
avatar RayTedwell

ha, nice idea. Just have a look at your shadows though, the shadows under the benches you placed in are very different to the ones for the fence and cows (much stronger and more directly underneath) that will help. Oh and have a look at the light and shade on the cows too

(5 years and 3704 days ago)

Cow Tipping
avatar RayTedwell

so sad, but a nice find and I like the angle of the shot (all he needs now is a chalk outline)

(5 years and 3707 days ago)

Mouse Dropping
avatar RayTedwell

nice funny idea, but the perspective of the walls bothers me a bit, you would be seeing them from different angles

(5 years and 3707 days ago)

How
avatar RayTedwell

Just stunning - beautiful work!

(5 years and 3709 days ago)

Strings on Swans
avatar RayTedwell

That must be a very big snail, or very small bird :P. I love the image though, great imagination and execution to match

(5 years and 3709 days ago)

Smallest bagpipe band
avatar RayTedwell

He is a bit lighter than the other little guys (meerkat's btw Josh), and the masking around his head is a little blurry too. There is a good tutorial around here - puss in boots if I remember correctly, about how to recreate the fur - or you could stick a hat on him ;p
Great idea though and overall very well done

(5 years and 3709 days ago)

Saxy Kat
avatar RayTedwell

nice simple idea but well executed

(5 years and 3709 days ago)

I see you
avatar RayTedwell

sorry but it looks more like blue material sitting on the grass - not quite realistic enough to be puddles

(5 years and 3709 days ago)

Puddles
avatar RayTedwell

It is certainly an abstract composition, but nicely put together. Personally, I would just like to have seen a bit more focus on the source image.

(5 years and 3709 days ago)

Space target bus
avatar RayTedwell

Great effects with her eyes, and his glasses! I see where you're going and I like the concept, but I have to say I would have preferred one big image of the bag scene, thats where the effort is and it deserves more attention!

(5 years and 3710 days ago)

Bag Lady
avatar RayTedwell

Author, without wanting to sound harsh, if you have no interest in improving your skills or receiving constructive feedback, then this is not the place to submit your work! Take on board the feedback these people give you - I'll hold off my vote for now to see if you do

(5 years and 3710 days ago)

Zippo Fire Alarm
avatar RayTedwell

great chop - feels like someone's just opened up a really old locker to let a stream of light in. Good imagination and execution (even if it does have stitches in it :P)

(5 years and 3711 days ago)

Fight another day
avatar RayTedwell

I think it all depends on how you define 'materials', is it other materials such as fabrics, or any materials, props or any other OBJECTS full stop - the theme rules should be stated more clearly - perhaps someone can clear this up for us?

(5 years and 3711 days ago)

Kourelou.
avatar RayTedwell

Nice job. Can I ask if you thought about trying it with some back lighting? That might give a glow to the top of the flames and remove the shadows - just a thought

(5 years and 3711 days ago)

flames
avatar RayTedwell

simple and dramatic, just great!

(5 years and 3712 days ago)

SUNSET
avatar RayTedwell

I can see what you have done, it almost looks as though you have left the next aged but as you move up the face it becomes more youthful - complete with a twinkle in the eye. Very poetic description in your previous post too, just beautiful!

(5 years and 3714 days ago)

Last X-Mas
avatar RayTedwell

What a great idea - love to see people think differently but still not lose the point of the theme post. I would adjust the left corner of the pic and dodge in some ligter spots for the highlights though. Oh and consider lightly smudging or blurring the edges just a little, no printing on a clog is going to be quite that precise. Cheers

(5 years and 3714 days ago)

Really Dutch
avatar RayTedwell

The colours and lighting are awesome. My only minor critiques are that three of the windmill blades are solid, but the one over the windmill base is not, and the 'bones' on the dragon's wing seem to be a bit opaque.

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Dragon Heaven mill
avatar RayTedwell

Beautiful! I'm trying to think of anything I'd change, but there really isn't anything!

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Silent Night
avatar RayTedwell

great choice of source image - well exectuted. Top job!

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

A private place
avatar RayTedwell

Nicely done, I'm glad you avouded the temptation to clutter up the night sky and detract focus from the house

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Then It Became Night
avatar RayTedwell

i completely agree with greymval, you did a great job on the 'northern lights' so have the focus on that. I would go even further and dull the stars a little too.

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Alaskan Night Life
avatar RayTedwell

great work!

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Silent Night
avatar RayTedwell

I like the effect but the realism isnt quite there. Because you have used the same shadows as the daytime photo the lighsource is coming from in the sky on the left (ie was the sun). This doesnt fit with having the moon in the centre of the pic (which btw doesnt quite line up with the reflection of the moon. Perhaps if you removed the moon and gave the sky a slight yellow tinge it might help??

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Singapore
avatar RayTedwell

Nice, I'd have never made the link from fish head to flower petal. Well done

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Colourful Garden
avatar RayTedwell

good use of colours, youve created a nice mood with this pic

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Berry Jewel
avatar RayTedwell

... well if you love raspberries that much I can see how that would be dissapointing These sort of posts seem to bring out different interpretations

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

scary berry
avatar RayTedwell

Nice. Simple but funny idea, I like it

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

Gaudi Luxury Caravan
avatar RayTedwell

I dont see how this is on theme, if anything youve added drama to an ordinary raspberry. The actual image is nice though

(5 years and 3715 days ago)

scary berry
avatar RayTedwell

I agree, shrink the plane a little.Also for me, the waves in the water detract focus from the buildings so maybe you could crop the bottom of the image a little?

(5 years and 3716 days ago)

World Mill Trade Centar
avatar RayTedwell

Very nice, I really like the lighting. Personally I would have focussed on the ghost girl and taken out the spider and faces on the bed but that's just a personal choice. Good job.

(5 years and 3716 days ago)

The Closet
avatar RayTedwell

Great idea and really well executed - You'll be tough to beat!

(5 years and 3716 days ago)

Trapped!
avatar RayTedwell

This is definitely one of the creepiest entries I've seen. Can I ask if the butterflies have a specific meaning, I can't seem to decide if I think they add to or detract from the overall effect...

(5 years and 3716 days ago)

dead born