641 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

would have been better without the berry in the top left, Hindsight is such a great thing.

(5 years and 2991 days ago)

Berries
avatar dustfinger

I like it when there is a story behind an image. Already some nice work here, but there is room for improvement.
To increase the contrast between foreground and background you could shift the hue of the foreground more to yellow or orange. Also, it would be nice if the tree was much bigger, extending more to the right. If you only show a small part of the leaves, it will give the impression that the whole tree is huge.

(5 years and 2991 days ago)

Banished
no avatar
pshoudini says:

this is a great peace of art and i can tell you put some efort into it.

i'm just trying to find where did you use the original carrot file that was provided for this contest. of course it may be just me who isnt finding it.

good job anyways

(5 years and 2991 days ago)

Banished
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Suggest creating more contrast between foreground & background. Would also be good to light the floating things the same as the castle.

(5 years and 2992 days ago)

Banished
avatar Drivenslush

it could use a bit of a whole dodge wash or some sort of brightening filter to bring up the detail (this could be my eyes but the image looks dark and a bit mushy) it's a great image overall and as always IMHO.. good hard work

(5 years and 2992 days ago)

Banished
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Interesting image but to small usage of the source image...

(5 years and 2992 days ago)

Banished
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!!

(5 years and 2992 days ago)

Door to Paradise
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!!

(5 years and 2992 days ago)

Waiting...
avatar Eladine
Eladine says:

I love the image but as much where it comes to use of source image i cant really give a high score

(5 years and 2992 days ago)

The Tree
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The use of the carrot leaves in the background is almost negligible, since you can't make out what they are. This is a lovely image, but the use of the contest source photo is very, very hard to discern within it. Submitting it to the stylus contest would be more logical, since you can somewhat make out that contest source image...Still, an excellent effort, combining many disparate images into a cohesive picture.

(5 years and 2993 days ago)

The Tree
no avatar
pshoudini says:

its a nice composition, but i cant really tell where you used the original source provided for the contest.

(5 years and 2993 days ago)

The Tree
avatar erathion
erathion says:

I still don't see where u used provided contest source image author...If u are new on PXL please read rules and guidelines...http://www.pxleyes.com/guidelines/

(5 years and 2993 days ago)

The Tree
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

You need to post links to all sources used, or post your own uncut photos in the SBS.
And BTW, I have no idea how the carrot source or stylus were used in your image, despite the SBS.

(5 years and 2993 days ago)

The Tree
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

Nice Job Congrats

(5 years and 2993 days ago)

Pumpkin
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The head is distorted in proportion. Her forehead looks huge, and her hairline too far back on the side.

(5 years and 2996 days ago)

Red
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

Great work, only point I'd make is, I would have (if had had been able to create the rest of the image) soften the skin, especially on the legs as they look far to real in this lovely fantasy image.

(5 years and 2996 days ago)

Waiting...
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

cute

(5 years and 2996 days ago)

Jupiter
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

he looks ready to bite

(5 years and 2996 days ago)

Vicious Beast
avatar CrystleClear

too cute!

(5 years and 2996 days ago)

Jupiter
avatar jordyponce

My fav!..

(5 years and 2996 days ago)

Waiting...
avatar Drivenslush

love the mirror effect good luck author

(5 years and 2997 days ago)

Door to Paradise
avatar nbaztec
nbaztec says:

Great chop author
The snow beneath the fountains is unconvincing. The one to the right isn't completely joined. Nice blending otherwise. Good luck.

(5 years and 2997 days ago)

Door to Paradise
avatar Akassa
Akassa says:

The things seem out of perspective, they're placed as if the model had her back to us when she gives one side. Otherwise very good abstract concept.

(5 years and 2997 days ago)

Waiting...
avatar Alan2641
Alan2641 says:

Very nice choice of images and great work on getting them into this -- one small thing is that the edges of the "Seat" need some touch up they are a bit ragged and still show some trace of the original background -- maybe some blur or soft brush on the mask would smooth it out.

(5 years and 2999 days ago)

Waiting...
avatar ciulama
ciulama says:

this entry needs more votes

(5 years and 2999 days ago)

Waiting...
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

Congratulations on 2nd place, so different from anything else I have seen from you.

(5 years and 3000 days ago)

Pumpkin
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

great setup and photo.

(5 years and 3002 days ago)

Pumpkin
avatar kyricom
kyricom says:

One of the better ones for the theme... just wish it were a touch brighter

(5 years and 3022 days ago)

Painting the Rose Red
avatar orientallad

now this is on theme, excellent shot, good luck

(5 years and 3023 days ago)

Painting the Rose Red
avatar ctbugan
ctbugan says:

This is an awesome picture. The fresh red paint and drops bring the whole thing to life. Great choice of colors as well.

(5 years and 3024 days ago)

Painting the Rose Red
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

Just a closer crop would improve it.

(5 years and 3027 days ago)

Painting the Rose Red
avatar robvdn
robvdn says:

I would have loved it if you caught the paint dripping from the leaf in a close up with more lightning on the rose. Could have made a great composition. The hand & brush are disturbing to me TBH....

Maybe you can re-shoot it?

(5 years and 3029 days ago)

Painting the Rose Red
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Great perspective for this photo, it really enhances the image by bringing it down to "ground level." Nice paint job!

(5 years and 3030 days ago)

Roadside pickup
avatar drskn08
drskn08 says:

hahahha loved it...!

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Masked Mutt
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

He sat still so he could sue you later.

(5 years and 3040 days ago)

Masked Mutt
avatar kyricom
kyricom says:

THAT... is pretty funny!

(5 years and 3040 days ago)

Masked Mutt
avatar robvdn
robvdn says:

If it wasn't for the reflections in the glass it would be worldclass, now it's awesome

(5 years and 3040 days ago)

Grow
avatar Artifakts
Artifakts says:

Nice shot but I think you playes a little bit too much with the levels. Dark parts are really ... black and a lot of details are lost.

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Waterfall
avatar kushpatel
kushpatel says:

amazing

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Natural Framing
avatar kyricom
kyricom says:

Very nice colors

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Natural Framing
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Yep, beautiful.

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Natural Framing
avatar captgeo
captgeo says:

Wow.... where is this?

(5 years and 3046 days ago)

Waterfall
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Can't appreciate the focal point through all the smoke. Artistic, but hides the beauty of the nose shape...

(5 years and 3046 days ago)

Up in Smoke
avatar bandit69
bandit69 says:

Magic mushroom? I agree with friiskiwi then. Great find!

(5 years and 3047 days ago)

Magic Mushroom
avatar poetress59

Wow...I almost posted a very similar picture! LOL. I find the mushrooms in my area so fascinating and in such a variety of colors and textures. Awesome job.

(5 years and 3051 days ago)

Magic Mushroom
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

It doesn't look real. It's so unusual and pretty, I thought it was glazed ceramic...What a wonderful find! Great photo, with a wonderful balance of values and colors. Really nice!!!

(5 years and 3051 days ago)

Magic Mushroom
avatar drskn08
drskn08 says:

wow.. purple mushroom ! never saw one..must be poisonous.

(5 years and 3052 days ago)

Magic Mushroom
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

What a great find.

(5 years and 3052 days ago)

Magic Mushroom
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

beautiful

(5 years and 3052 days ago)

Natural Framing
avatar JoeCacia
JoeCacia says:

LOL! Nice one author!

(5 years and 3063 days ago)

Opposites Attract