2912 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar still26
still26 says:

This one really lends itself to selective colour technique. I like how the man is absorbed and not aware of photographer. The fact that he is looking down at the selected colourful pens is an added visual guide and a bonus to the photo.

(5 years and 777 days ago)

Gabriel
avatar still26
still26 says:

Love this beautiful little girl in full colour and she is nicely framed by Minnie Mouse.

(5 years and 777 days ago)

I can see you!
avatar still26
still26 says:

I want to walk here with you and look for leprechauns and fairies. Lovely mood evoking image.

(5 years and 777 days ago)

In the woods of mystery
avatar still26
still26 says:

Quite artistic. Nice composition and feel to this, a photo that invites one to study it and get absorbed.

(5 years and 777 days ago)

New morning
avatar still26
still26 says:

Great title so apropos. Love the warm colours and those ghosts really pop and make the image a mystery.

(5 years and 777 days ago)

Ghosts in the field
avatar still26
still26 says:

OMG I can taste this gooey-ness. Great entry showing that runny cheese and the inclusion of board and checkerboard napkin gives it an extra visual bump.

(5 years and 777 days ago)

Cheeeeeeeese!
avatar still26
still26 says:

Nice one cherie.

(5 years and 777 days ago)

Decaying wood
avatar madamemonty
Moderator says:

Any photo of a copyright image has broken the copyright laws. The wiki image actually has copyright on it and can not be used. There are images of Johnny Depp that are licensed under creative commons.

(5 years and 777 days ago)

Sweeney Todd
avatar madamemonty
Moderator says:

Source No 1 the book can not be used. Images that are photos of posters, book covers, other printed images or even photos of other photographs can't be used because the images used to create the poster, book or whatever are most probably copyrighted and taking a picture of them violates the copyright.

(5 years and 778 days ago)

Sweeney Todd
avatar photonut
photonut says:

Really clever this,and although you cropped his head still like it

(5 years and 779 days ago)

Gabriel
avatar photonut
photonut says:

your welcome,i like the stallholders expression in this

(5 years and 780 days ago)

Sunday market
avatar photonut
photonut says:

Interesting view of a market this.

(5 years and 781 days ago)

Sunday market
avatar George55
George55 says:

Congratulations.

(5 years and 782 days ago)

Music on the top
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Where is everyone?

(5 years and 782 days ago)

Music on the top
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Congratulations Z.

(5 years and 782 days ago)

Music on the top
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Not true. People help each other all the time. I change my Chops due to people's suggestions all the time. For example in this one George55 & CMYK46 suggested that I move some things around and change some colors here and there, which I did.

http://www.pxleyes.com/photoshop-picture/59ee63bf16f16/Staue-of-Liberty.html

(5 years and 783 days ago)

Preparing the magic potion
avatar BWR
BWR says:

That's so funny. I used that same with to make a Halloween Chop of my niece.

(5 years and 783 days ago)

Preparing the magic potion
avatar BWR
BWR says:

I like it too.

(5 years and 783 days ago)

Abstract dark portrait
avatar still26
still26 says:

Shot in low key and it is so appropriate. I love the fact that they are not all grinning at the camera for looking the way they do gives a ghoulish feel to the photo, yet we have one smile emanating from the little girl and that is a reminder that not all is sinister!

(5 years and 784 days ago)

Night visitors
avatar still26
still26 says:

To step into the world of a child (missing her tooth). This is a very inviting image and we are charmed by the child partaking in Halloween festivities. I really like how she is peering up at us through the dark veil. Your POV shows us her childlike fragility and makes the image more meaningful on a subconscious level. LOVE IT.

(5 years and 784 days ago)

Getting prepared
avatar still26
still26 says:

Good philosophical discussion here: to objectify a human strips them of their personality and dignity, they become a commodity. This monk is not a commodity, I pray I like the shot and it does echo of religion which is the title of this contest.

(5 years and 784 days ago)

Lost in thoughts
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Very nice.

(5 years and 785 days ago)

Halloween
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Good chop. The front where the fish and the witch are, looks dark, while the background looks light. Maybe darken the background some to make them match or lighten the foreground?

Also I bent the wood part of the mushroom and did this to the flying witch's legs. Maybe you will like it?

https://i.imgur.com/KgTQRsU.jpg


Maybe use the grass brush, #134, to blend the roots into the ground.

(5 years and 785 days ago)

Preparing the magic potion
avatar still26
still26 says:

Sweet, looks like me eating a banana. LOL

(5 years and 786 days ago)

Hungry baby
avatar skyangel
skyangel says:

Congratulations on 4th Sylvie. It's my favorite out of all your entries.

(5 years and 788 days ago)

Abstract dark portrait
avatar skyangel
skyangel says:

Congratulations Sylvie.

(5 years and 788 days ago)

In the museum
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

people can be an object

(5 years and 789 days ago)

Lost in thoughts
avatar Denlig
Denlig says:

Yes but but it's not an object...

(5 years and 789 days ago)

Lost in thoughts
avatar George55
George55 says:

Congratulations..

(5 years and 789 days ago)

In the museum
avatar BWR
BWR says:

HAHA!! Was checking out some old chops. This one made me laugh out loud and I sounded like a horse. Good times. These are the good old days!!

(5 years and 790 days ago)

Is it a bird, is it a plane?
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Advanced Tutorial: How to Select Difficult Hair in Photoshop CC
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=33tz2Xszil0

How to Cut Out ANYTHING in Photoshop (10 Tips and Tricks for Making Difficult Selections and Masks
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z6off4PVn8E

There are some really good methods for extracting stuff from the background. Channel Masking is really good and adding "Calculations" to that can make your life easier. With these methods you will find yourself not always relying on traditional methods of cutting things out. Sometimes it can take you an hour to cut something out, and using these methods it can be extracted in a minute or so.

I made a small sample of her hair from your source image. Took me 10 seconds. Fairly busy or I woulda done the rest. This is on a 50% Greay background https://i.imgur.com/DmzChuo.jpg

(5 years and 790 days ago)

Little night music
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Actually a pretty slick Chop. I like how you opened up the roof. Pretty imaginative.

(5 years and 791 days ago)

Rainy day
avatar photonut
photonut says:

Nice one this

(5 years and 792 days ago)

Lost in thoughts
avatar BWR
BWR says:

When you wish upon a star
Your dreams will take you very far
But when you wish upon a dream
Life ain't always what it seems
What'd you see on a night so clear
In the sky so very dear
You're a shining star
No matter who you are
Shining bright to see
What you could truly be

-Earth Wind and Fire

(5 years and 792 days ago)

Another world
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Nice job. No planet and/or moon?

(5 years and 792 days ago)

Another world
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Great work. Very nice source images. It may be a little dark or that could be my eyes or room lighting. Perhaps it's just the bottom left that's too dark and maybe one more white cloud in the sky. Also try to do the light a little better on the lantern. Man it looks so good in full res.

(5 years and 793 days ago)

From the sea cave
avatar BWR
BWR says:

We are Photshoppers. We have the eyes of an eagle.

(5 years and 794 days ago)

Homeless
avatar skyangel
skyangel says:

Congratulations Sylvie. Very nicely done.

(5 years and 796 days ago)

Globetrotters
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Nice chop. The boy and girl monkey in the front are very nice. The man's hair is fantastic! Maybe the girl's eyes are too dark? The boy monkey in the back, his hood is smudged. Here is a pic to show you.

https://i.imgur.com/e3Atoxs.jpg

(5 years and 796 days ago)

Homeless
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

I think the lenses would still look like those in the source pic.

(5 years and 796 days ago)

Little night music
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Nice job Zizounai.The waving man was perfect. So hard to find images that fit in so nice like that one.

(5 years and 796 days ago)

Globetrotters
avatar George55
George55 says:

Congratulations again....

(5 years and 796 days ago)

Drawing
avatar George55
George55 says:

Congratulations nice entry.

(5 years and 796 days ago)

I
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Congrats Z.

(5 years and 797 days ago)

A night at the dungeon
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Rain should be more visible.

(5 years and 798 days ago)

Rainy day
avatar BWR
BWR says:

YW. Very nice. Image is now more consistent. Looks so real I hope people don't vote low because they can't tell that almost everything is Photoshopped. (if you know what I mean)

(5 years and 800 days ago)

In the museum
avatar BWR
BWR says:

I like it. Work on the floor perspective just a bit. I know you have done some perspective work on it, but it needs more IMO.

(5 years and 800 days ago)

The cat princess
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Real nice work.

(5 years and 800 days ago)

Abstract dark portrait
avatar BWR
BWR says:

Very nice composite. All the people are blended well as far as lighting and color (temperature). I like how you made the source into a stone statue as well as the paintings. Impressive work I must say .

Couple suggestions. The 3 girls on the bench have reflections on the floor, whereas the statue/pedestal, and the three people standing do not. Also the standing people may have too much floor shadow as compared to the 3 that are sitting.

(5 years and 800 days ago)

In the museum
no avatar

sensational

(5 years and 801 days ago)

The cat princess