272 comments received ( finished contests only ):
no avatar

congrats... well placed 1st,, beaut entry.

(5 years and 3030 days ago)

Tropical Bird
avatar madamemonty

Congrats Elemare terrific work

(5 years and 3030 days ago)

Tropical Bird
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!!

(5 years and 3030 days ago)

Tropical Bird
no avatar

love this creative entry author.. the colour balance and source usage is FANTASTIC.

I love the expression on the birds face that has been created by incorp'ing the source and your artistic skills. WELL DONE... one for the FAVS.

(5 years and 3032 days ago)

Tropical Bird
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Brilliant work, love his expression, and the exhaust pipes on his head!

(5 years and 3032 days ago)

Tropical Bird
avatar DanLundberg

As lchappell noted, the mandolin and lace table cloth are very creative creations.

I think the shadows need refinement, however. The apple half should cast more shadow on the fruit that should cast more shadow on the mandolin that should cast more shadow on the wall. Furthermore, a shadow should be very intense (just one or two pixels wide) immediately under an object to ground it so it doesn't appear to be floating above the surface it's sitting upon. As the shadow extends away from the object, the shadow should be a gradient because ambient light weakens the shadow the farther away it gets from the object.

I would explore moving the painting northwest so it goes outside the frame of the image and has a greater overlap with the mandolin. Centering a table under the picture would also seem a more natural decorating choice. (An alternative would be to take the painting off the wall and rest it on the table.)

(5 years and 3032 days ago)

Still Life
avatar enblanco
enblanco says:

Wonderful author, GL!

(5 years and 3032 days ago)

Tropical Bird
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 3033 days ago)

Tropical Bird
avatar lchappell
lchappell says:

Very pretty, ingenious compilation of your sources. Some very good creation techniques used. The mandolin and the way you made the table cloth from the lace in particular. Good luck and congrats for a very nice piece.

(5 years and 3033 days ago)

Still Life
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good use of all elements of the source, and great expression on the bird!

(5 years and 3033 days ago)

Tropical Bird
avatar lolu
lolu says:

Congrats !

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar arca
arca says:

Great work and congrats!

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Room with a View... or Two
avatar arca
arca says:

Congrats!!! Very clever

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar madamemonty

Congrats again Elemare

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar madamemonty

Congrats Elemare wonderful room, I'd like it at my place

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Room with a View... or Two
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

congrats

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

congrats! well deserved 1st place!

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Room with a View... or Two
avatar jordyponce

Yeap..nice!..

(5 years and 3036 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Agree with Dan about the interior and exterior shot lighting difference. I'd never want to leave this room - and the use of wicker is perfect for this relaxing 'atmosphere'! Great job.

(5 years and 3037 days ago)

Room with a View... or Two
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Wow.. such painstaking work, beautiful result!

(5 years and 3037 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 3037 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 3037 days ago)

Room with a View... or Two
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 3037 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:


(5 years and 3037 days ago)

Lullaby
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Very sweet! Background is very interesting, it kind of makes a secluded enclosure. The texture on the little dragon was done well, I like that you left some parts without it. Great job with extraction of the fairy and Pan, too.

(5 years and 3037 days ago)

Lullaby
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Beautiful fairy tail girl

(5 years and 3038 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar cabldawg71

Very nice Author and I agree with Arca good luck

(5 years and 3038 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar arca
arca says:

Lovely image and beautifully done ... your "over-painting" really finishes the piece nicely. Great SBS ... you get extra points from me for that!!!

(5 years and 3039 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar aheman
aheman says:

nice adaptation .... background should be as simple as possible to have better focus
on the main objects

(5 years and 3039 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Interesting take on a boring source.

(5 years and 3040 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar DanLundberg

Interesting, but the central thing is too flat and indiscernable. Actually, I'm not sure why the central thing is necessary. (Delete the central thing and move the boy slightly in front of the girl.) Also, the trees in the background have as much depth as a painted flat in a high-school musical. So many flares is distracting IMO.

(5 years and 3040 days ago)

Lullaby
avatar lbadge320
lbadge320 says:

M.C. Escherish. Well done!

(5 years and 3041 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
avatar aheman
aheman says:

should make the whole image more "saturated" color of orange, now more black than orange

(5 years and 3041 days ago)

Lullaby
avatar drskn08
drskn08 says:

really interesting

(5 years and 3041 days ago)

Impossible Triangle
no avatar
andi says:

very very nice but i think there are some premade work , thats not allowed , like thr garden set

(5 years and 3042 days ago)

Room with a View... or Two
avatar Drivenslush

elegant and sweet (fantastic source find) GOOD LUCK!!!

(5 years and 3042 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar enblanco
enblanco says:

Very good work, GL!

(5 years and 3042 days ago)

Room with a View... or Two
avatar enblanco
enblanco says:

Interesting composition, GL!

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The sparkle brush on the fish is a wee bit over-dominant to the image, but the overall concept and execution is very well done!

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Lullaby
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

Congrats! great work!

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Bird
avatar DanLundberg

The highlights are orange and the highlights dominate the image, so it's orange enough for me. Reshaping the butterfly wings into something more dramatic was inspired. I'm not sure what happened in Step 4 of the SBS, but she started looking at her thumb instead of the butterfly which drastically minimizes the overall impact.

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar aheman
aheman says:

I like it, nice job on the blending/smoothening of lady..

like the in-between butterfly-firefly idea

easily could be an image in a fairytale book

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Nice, but 50% orange at best.

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar layerstack

FAB WORK!!!

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Forest Lights
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Very nice work, great mood.

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Out of the Storm
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

I didn't see it before, but it looks good now, your lighting work makes for a good atmosphere.

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Bad News Travels
avatar arca
arca says:

Great work!!!

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Bad News Travels
avatar arca
arca says:

Great work and nice SBS!

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Out of the Storm
avatar DanLundberg

The night exterior with the day interior is genius. The sconces are a creative way to convey greater solidity to the side walls, but the light they emit is apparently irrelevant to the illumination of the room. (They shine light up while their solid bases would cast shadows down.)

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Room with a View... or Two
no avatar
Keiley22 says:


i tawt i saw a putty cat

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Bird