5139 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

A nice touch would have been a green orange but that's just IMO

(5 years and 3583 days ago)

Peeled
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Agrees with CMYK46. Shadow is not necessary but better luck next time.

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

It
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

DanLundberg made some good points.

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

Hmm? Where
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Beautiful, stylish, very elegant looking... I think it is a perfect fit for my head he-he

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

Tiara
avatar Drivenslush

cute concept

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

Hmm? Where
avatar Drivenslush

very neat idea

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

What is that?
avatar siderismaris

superb

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

Tiara
no avatar
PSser says:

It does look like a phony UFO photo which is the idea right?

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

What is that?
avatar DanLundberg

If the notion is that the UFO caused the destruction, then the neatly cut tree stump doesn't fit. The shadows on the alien aren't consistent with those on the stump. The UFO seems tilted downward (vanishing point much too high for this Earthling's predisposition). The top edge of the UFO doesn't seem realistic because it's so strong.

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

Hmm? Where
avatar DanLundberg

Cool vantage point. I don't think the UFO undersides should not be so brightly lit, however, as I would expect them to be in shadow.

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

What is that?
avatar Lamantine
Lamantine says:

nice job

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

It
avatar Lamantine
Lamantine says:

lol i like his expression good job !

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

Hmm? Where
avatar Lamantine
Lamantine says:

nice idea

(5 years and 3584 days ago)

What is that?
avatar PixelWhisperer

lovely, nice touch with the reflection, imo tones of images too jarring... well done

(5 years and 3585 days ago)

Ballerina
avatar PixelWhisperer

well done

(5 years and 3585 days ago)

I
avatar PixelWhisperer

well done but would the seam be on the inside too?

(5 years and 3585 days ago)

Peeled
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Very nice work...good luck author

(5 years and 3586 days ago)

I
avatar Drivenslush

very well done!!!!

(5 years and 3586 days ago)

Creature
avatar Barnacle
Barnacle says:

lol, and a joke it is.

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

It
avatar gamemastertips

It's meant to be a joke, Barnacle.

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

It
avatar Barnacle
Barnacle says:

I dunno if he'd need binoculars to see the craft.

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

It
no avatar
jpmackey says:

Clever. I don't think you need the light glow from the 'foo cause it's broad daylight.

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

It
avatar gamemastertips

Yes, and the light is coming from the top-right...the makes the shadow correct, no?

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

It
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

LOL...the shadow is still wrong...look at the angle of the shadow on the man's hand.

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

It
avatar gamemastertips

Hmm better. Maybe try dodging and burning it a bit to make it look more like an orb, and maybe try cutting out a real pane of glass (if you can find a suitable one, of course) to use for the spacecraft. That should make it look pretty realistic if that's what you're aiming for. Also try a bit of guassian blur on the shadow. Shadows tend to be blurred more when they're more distant away from the object casting it.

(5 years and 3587 days ago)

It
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, I meant the shadow is too small. Just get rid of it if you can't figure out how to do it right. According to the light source, it wouldn't be visible in the pic anyway. Look at the angle of the light on the man.

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

It
avatar gamemastertips

Haha very cute. I like the added humor with the binoculars and the craft size (it's good tiny!). My only complaint would be is that it's obviously fake, and the contest states to make it as realistic as possible. With a bit more work you could be able to achieve this (only if you want, of course), and you'd have a really clever entry.

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

It
avatar Drivenslush

it's EVE without a body ...hehehehe.. very cute entry

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

It
avatar DanLundberg

Cute. I personally think the big green glow and the white flare detract. The base flange needs more shadow to be consistent with the shadow on the globe.

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

It
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Light source is from upper right, the round shadow wouldn't be there. It's too small anyway...

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

It
avatar shgallerymag

Great work! Very creative.

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

I
avatar Lamantine
Lamantine says:

creepy... nice idea

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

Creature
avatar hereisanoop

nice and scraaaary....

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

Creature
avatar eyelander
eyelander says:

Bravo! The feathers looks great...

(5 years and 3588 days ago)

I
avatar langstrum
langstrum says:

Erika, I like this cat

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Fur and blanket
avatar inanis
inanis says:

great image. also sbs is explicit enough, it't not a tutorial but a sbs after all. good kuck to you.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

I
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good job making the bird. SBS could be more complete.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

I
avatar gamemastertips

Wow....that is awesome. Very powerful and great idea.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

I
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Well done!

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Fur and blanket
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

Another of those animals that want maximum protection. Good job you have done here, Best of luck!

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Armor-dillo
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

A little too simple for my taste.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Date under sunset
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

creative changes, Good luck with this.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Date under sunset
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

Good luck!

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Captive
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Very surreal image.

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Watercolor and paper dreams
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Nice work...i think would be better if u give some other tone to ballerina image...maybe red-ish...good luck author

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Ballerina
avatar Lamantine
Lamantine says:

nice idea good one

(5 years and 3589 days ago)

Ballerina
avatar Jellopudding

Haven't you guys ever watched horror movies... she was more then likely beaten and tortured in other areas and then returned to suffer alone... or it's a rp s&m bondage kinkiness .. :P I like it

(5 years and 3590 days ago)

Captive
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Well done!

(5 years and 3591 days ago)

Armor-dillo
avatar hereisanoop

coooll work,,,

(5 years and 3591 days ago)

Armor-dillo
avatar Barnacle
Barnacle says:

Nice work, idea and title

Edit: it's right leg looks to burnt.

(5 years and 3591 days ago)

Armor-dillo