1055 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Perhaps a bit of free transform skewing on the body to "angle" her back a bit would help the perspective. I like the concept, but agree about the jellyfish, more because as compared to morey (morels are mushrooms) eels, a jellyfish has no real brain or personality, and those tendrils sting, no matter who they touch, friend or foe...

@DollMommy ~ While comments can be kudos and back pats, here they also serve the purpose of pointing out visual inconsistencies and technical flaws and errors to *theoretically* help the artist become better at chopping an image. Hence, what you term "nit picks" are quite often merely observations of flaws that prevent the image from visually communicating the artist's vision. Not every creation is a "masterpiece," and just because it was made does not excuse it from critical commentary.

Perspective, Lighting, and Edges are the three most important compositional parts of a good Chop. When they are flawed, it brings the entire image down, regardless the author's subjective intent.

(5 years and 3321 days ago)

Sea Witch
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

I think we really need an instruction on how to leave a constructive comment instead of just giving nit picks. It seems to me that this is the artists vision and deserves the respect from all of us. The artist might take the suggestions to heart if there were more positive comments prior to making such strong suggestions on how to improve upon the piece. Ideas presented the way Nator has done could be a lesson to us all.
Personally, I think this shows allot of imagination and the artist evidently spent allot of time in it's creation. Art is subjective and means something different to all of us

(5 years and 3321 days ago)

Sea Witch
avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

I feel like without the jellyfish you could make your creature a little larger, which would really make her the main focus, especially because the colour of the tentacles is very similar to the hue of the water.

Good luck

(5 years and 3322 days ago)

Sea Witch
avatar k5683
k5683 says:

ha ha, I had taken a picture of myself like this in Black and White also but it didn't come out that clear so I didn't upload it.

(5 years and 3322 days ago)

Goofy
avatar DanLundberg

Maybe if the center of the legs lined up with the line going down the center of her torso and if the legs were horizontally flipped or else rotated clockwise so her near-side legs are lower than her far-side legs (i.e., have legs conform more to the diagonal angle of her gaze). More feeling of front-to-back depth would also add interest; everything seems to be mid-ground with no truly foreground or background elements. For example, fish brushes creating a small school of fish at 11 o'clock plus a bigger jelly fish at 4 o'clock would enhance the diagonality. I also think a tad (1 or 2 pixels, I imagine) more shadow beneath the starfish pasties is needed to make it clear that they are on top of her breasts.

(5 years and 3322 days ago)

Sea Witch
avatar creativefreedom

I must say its a GREAT shot but I cant look, SCARY!!!!!!!!!!!!!! GOOD JOB!!!!

(5 years and 3322 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar creativefreedom

ALL I can say is WOWWWWWWWWWW!!!!!!!

(5 years and 3323 days ago)

Key to My Heart
avatar shaadow
shaadow says:

Am I seeing a Hollywood Movie!!!!!!!, fantastic entry in a fantastic contest. GL

(5 years and 3323 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar langstrum
langstrum says:

That's not surprised to me, author, because I also realized that your style is unique and stable through all of your entries. Your ideas behind the entries easily impress people and your execution is clever. As far as this entry is concerned, you achieved your goal for sure. Even though this contest will be full of mermaids, maybe I won't see any spooky mermaid like that again because that's too difficult to compete with you . I just have a suggestion of increasing the brightness of the whole scene for people to appreciate more what you've done. Best of luck to you
EDIT: Oops, I'm sorry, sometimes siren is depicted as a kind of mermaid but in general they are distinctive.

(5 years and 3323 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

Oh, no, I always got surprised when I see the wonderful stuff that is shown here in this site! Everybody (including the author) is very talented, I have no words.
And this entry is cool, the title really means "evil" deeply! GL!

(5 years and 3324 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar Mikaelbg
Mikaelbg says:

Brilliant

(5 years and 3324 days ago)

Big Wheel
avatar GiaArt
GiaArt says:

OMG Awesomely Spoooooky! Love It

(5 years and 3324 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar RayTedwell

I love this. Nice original take on the theme, and the lighting and tone of the shot work really well. Top marks from me.

(5 years and 3324 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar MnMCarta
MnMCarta says:

great shot! I always have a hard time with places this dark but you pulled it off nicely!

(5 years and 3324 days ago)

Jammin
no avatar
andi says:

ok verry good GL

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
no avatar
andi says:

NICE but is the tale premade by another person ??? is that alowed ???

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar MnMCarta
MnMCarta says:

WOW!!! This is a good choice for this contest! Love it.

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Big Wheel
avatar Lamantine
Lamantine says:

Of course you do

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar MnMCarta
MnMCarta says:

well doesn't she look nice and friendly! LOL Great job on this!

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar Akassa
Akassa says:

It's good to have a style, your own style there's many ppl with a style here, which is not bad in my opinion.

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar hereisanoop

great stuff..... and author u too have a trademark style.... I can recognize you...

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar Lamantine
Lamantine says:

Absolutely fabulous ! 100% on theme. Really beautiful work, high marks from me ! (And why am I not surprised its you ? )

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar nishagandhi

wow thats creepy ! well done

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar Akassa
Akassa says:

Oh that's an amazing scene and idea. I think you should bet more on shading to give it a higher dynamic.

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Evil Siren
avatar cocor
cocor says:

Nice and terryfying...

(5 years and 3325 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

I knew it!!!

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

"The Unexamined Life...
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Nice!!!! GL!

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

"The Unexamined Life...
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Now this this I was surprised to see it was you but still impressed. GL!

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

below the forest giants
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

I KNEW IT!!!! Nice entry! GL!

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

through the looking glass
avatar lchappell
lchappell says:

That sure is one UGLY heifer.

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

"The Unexamined Life...
avatar EmiK
EmiK says:

Very original, wish I had though of that, but than again not sure if I would be able to do this = )

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar erathion
erathion says:

great surrealism author...best of luck

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

Key to My Heart
avatar erathion
erathion says:

cool work author...good luck

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

"The Unexamined Life...
avatar erathion
erathion says:

wow cool creation...best of luck author

(5 years and 3326 days ago)

Sunny Day Feeling
avatar nishagandhi

cool work

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

Sunny Day Feeling
avatar solkee
solkee says:

Great imagination, lovely entry.

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

Sunny Day Feeling
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

Agree with all above.

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar locksmagic

Creepy, nice idea though

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar craigers
craigers says:

got my attention, well done!

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar donarkz
donarkz says:

Hollow! from BLEACH!

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

"The Unexamined Life...
avatar Alan2641
Alan2641 says:

nice image -- well nice is a sort of eerie way

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Definitely original... and creepy. GL!

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

Rolled like Marbles
avatar JPDesigns
JPDesigns says:

I like this. Its sweet and the girl is well made Nice, author.

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

Sunny Day Feeling
avatar artgirl1935

I hope viewers will go into the hi res on this work to really appreciate how well done it is. GL

(5 years and 3327 days ago)

through the looking glass
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

nice shot under difficult conditions.

(5 years and 3328 days ago)

Jammin
avatar arca
arca says:

Fairytale worthy and well crafted piece. Good work!

(5 years and 3328 days ago)

below the forest giants
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

beautifully done

(5 years and 3328 days ago)

Sorrow
avatar arca
arca says:

Who ... are ... you ... to create such a wonderful (pun alert) image as this! Just love the whole thing ... your lighting is great ... feels like being in another world ... down a rabbit hole perhaps?

(5 years and 3328 days ago)

through the looking glass
avatar arca
arca says:

Creepy! Truly creepy. Good work!

(5 years and 3328 days ago)

"The Unexamined Life...
avatar Alan2641
Alan2641 says:

Figure is very nicely made and the over all look is great -- only one small thing is the shoulder seems a bit too blurred compared to the balance of the figure.

(5 years and 3328 days ago)

Sunny Day Feeling