Pretty convincing, nice job. Good luck!

Look at your source pic...the reflection could look more realistic, fading out at the bottom.

Spectacular! Only one thing was flipped. The reflection just matched accordingly!

indeed, but you turned 2 things upside down

great attention to reflection.

Awesome!

wow, this couldnt get much worse, could it?

you were striving for accuracy?

Congrats!!!! great job!!!!

ok I don't mind the moon nice effort Author good luck

The opacity of the water reflection needs to be turned down a little, as it over powers the rest of the photo.

Nice vibrant colors.

Extraordinary!

yes, I agree with losing the moon..........the aurora is enough!

i completely agree with greymval, you did a great job on the 'northern lights' so have the focus on that. I would go even further and dull the stars a little too.

The moon is well reflected, but i vote for no moon. I think you introduced it to make the composition more interesting, but now it's a competition between the moon and the aurora borealis, and the image lost it's focus center. IMO the ship and Aurora would be more than enough.

Wow!

nice

cmyk............not at all...........the moon will be reflected just the same as the mountains will be reflected, as far as the water is concerned, the moon is the same level as the mountains.

Moon is too low to be reflected...

Oh No watch out for the Plane...Great Edit....VTD

this reminds me of photos iv seen of the northen light

simple and thought provoking, good luck.

It really looks like my MOM when she was that age.. WOW.. very nice image.. You really captured the time!!!

Congratulations for 2nd

Nice sentiment, and a very good drawing. I wish you the best of luck!

Congrats!!

Congrats

congrats!

Congrats Loyd!

Seems like the boat is colored funny and the glare over the right side of the mountain seems a bit bright.

despite low-quality main image, this is very clean work.

you can see it is not a trace. fantastic work author. i love the finish on the hair and background.

Congrats for your second place, Loyd!

great

MUCH better! good thing i don't vote up until next sunday

Nice, I like it

well, then i guess i must have misinterpreted the image.. the plane and the zeppelin seem one next to each other which is obviously impossible due to their sizes.. i think seperating the red plane from the zeppelin a bit more might help. in this image the zeppelin is farthest away, right? i dunno, that little plane looks like it's very far, but it's too big i think the sharpnes and blur play a role here.. the zeppelin is sharper than the red plane and i think there's the conflict. that black plane is too sharp too imo.
also, you could contract the zepp and the red plane by a pixel or so to get rid of the white outline.
i hope i have been helpful, author

there's too much going on.. you also have proportion issues.

The idea is excelelnt, but CMYK is right, the do look distorted.

This is not on theme, is three time on theme. Good job, author, GL.

Purdy cool!!! (though I love anything that looks even remotely like a Torah... and I'm a Catholic LOL)

Try to fix the distortion on the knight & dragon. (Hit Shift key when scaling).

Nice entry but the mans shadows are on the wrong side compared to the table and room.

*
i think some people need to remember that with art, and themes, we should use the theme as a starting point, not a finishing point, what i mean is this author has followed the theme very well by creating "old maps" beyond that, this author has also taken the time to place those "old maps" into an everyday "real" scene, it is my opinion , that this type entry is far better than an entry that only makes the "old map" and displays it as a flat image ,

Love the image.....who cares about maps.........where's the horse the girl rode in on??? Seriously, I DO like the image.

Then what you should of done was concentrate on those three maps you made and uploaded them as separate entries.

nice entry, looks like it could be a winner

something about that grass scares me.

I've heard of pimp my ride but pimp my tractor?? *LOL*