40 comments received ( finished contests only ):
no avatar

Awesome! Looks right where he belongs.

(5 years and 2397 days ago)

Key Holder
avatar dustfinger

The two mastodonts are nicely blended, but the perspective of the candlestick does not match with the background. Speaking of that. What is the source of the background?

(5 years and 2471 days ago)

Candlestick
avatar DanielaOwergoor

Yes, the concept is great!!!
I loved this one!
Good luck, author!

(5 years and 2913 days ago)

The shooting range
no avatar
ps.robgd says:

Try to rotate the arows' tails (on the arrows that are tail visible only) because they look too repetitive.

(5 years and 2914 days ago)

The shooting range
avatar Alan2641
Alan2641 says:

like the idea -- find the colurs on the pumkins a bit over saturated -- tone them down maybe or try a different blending mode

(5 years and 2914 days ago)

The shooting range
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

A bit too blue, the leaves look very unnatural, but a great concept!

(5 years and 2914 days ago)

The shooting range
avatar Eladine
Eladine says:

there you go.. is a far better scene now nice job on the mill too to cover up the wings.. the main thing thats bothering now is the cutout of the dafodils they have a black and greyish outline and miss parts in the leafs.

(5 years and 2943 days ago)

Alice
avatar Drivenslush

author, as Elad has said, you have a very winning concept here, but the Hi Res shows a LOT of detail that will give you low votes, especially from the more powerful voters... the design is FANTASTIC but the detail needs to be refined.. GOOD LUCK!!!

(5 years and 2943 days ago)

Alice
avatar Eladine
Eladine says:

Its a very nice scene you have setup there, but you need to work on some details to make this a winner the daffodils on the right, you need to cut them out way better.. I dont know what you used but you cut parts of the leafs n more. theres a black outline on the flowerpetals aswell. I like to suggest you to use the pentool for the cutout, if you dont now how then heres a very good tutorial for beginners with pentool. http://www.melissaevans.com/tutorials/how-to-use-photoshops-pen-tool/1 page 1 explains the pentool and page 2 tells you bhow to cut out using the pentool. The floor the girl is standing on, remove it and make her feet stand in the sand, also i dont understand what happened to her feet they are all wobbly

The mill arms that are still vissible you can cover up by using parts of the mill with the same structure. copy past and even flip parts that you can use.

If you work on these things then you can really have a nice scene here good luck

(5 years and 2943 days ago)

Alice
avatar WYSIWYG
WYSIWYG says:

Nice one!

(5 years and 2946 days ago)

Sky light
avatar JoeCacia
JoeCacia says:

Lovely, I am the running princess
Best of luck author!

(5 years and 2948 days ago)

Escape from the Prince
no avatar
bilo1087 says:

a lot of lamps
nice idea

(5 years and 2948 days ago)

Sky light
no avatar
ha_ko2008 says:

good

(5 years and 2948 days ago)

Sky light
avatar jadedink
jadedink says:

selections around the hair could use some blending work. try using a layer mask when you extract things.
also, the background could use some realism. instead of a dark sky with a noise filter, perhaps use an actual picture of a night sky.
also, the mask looks flat compared to the face, like a cut out placed over a picture. using some blending techniques and perhaps something other than straight black would help.
We are all here to learn... i wish you luck!!!

(5 years and 2948 days ago)

Escape from the Prince
no avatar

love it.. creativity wise, i wonder what it would have been like if it had been a night scene.

(5 years and 2948 days ago)

Sky light
avatar secretsather

Nice!

(5 years and 2948 days ago)

Sky light
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

You rotated the shadow about 45 degrees. Better than nothing, but you need to develop an eye for light sources.

(5 years and 2949 days ago)

Sky light
no avatar
ha_ko2008 says:

A good idea

(5 years and 2950 days ago)

Sky light
no avatar
ha_ko2008 says:

A good idea

(5 years and 2950 days ago)

Sky light
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Soften the edge of the light beam on the child at right. The shadow should be rotated 90 degrees clockwise to match the light from the bulb. Bulbs on ground would have shadows.

(5 years and 2951 days ago)

Sky light