187 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

Actually, if you look the lighting source, the moon couldn't appear, it would be on the left behind of who looks the image. But, it gives a mood on the image; as elficho and rufkut say, move the image of the moon to the left to fix it.

(5 years and 3403 days ago)

Midnight
avatar rufkut
rufkut says:

The ground is blurred compared to the rest of the image but great idea author. GL

(5 years and 3403 days ago)

Beach at phone
avatar rufkut
rufkut says:

Create smog for the polution it will help your image.

(5 years and 3403 days ago)

Polution...
avatar rufkut
rufkut says:

I agree with elficho if you look at the buildings you will see that the light source is coming from the left. Switch the moon to the left side and you will have a better image author. GL

(5 years and 3403 days ago)

Midnight
avatar Tuckinator

hahahaah very cool

(5 years and 3404 days ago)

Beach at phone
avatar Tuckinator

um
simple

(5 years and 3404 days ago)

Polution...
avatar Tuckinator

nice

(5 years and 3404 days ago)

Midnight
avatar elficho
elficho says:

it turned out good, but you won't get high scores for this kind of work

(5 years and 3404 days ago)

Polution...
avatar elficho
elficho says:

cool, but wrong light source. the moon should be on the diagonal side

(5 years and 3404 days ago)

Midnight
avatar erathion
erathion says:

very nice using of details...good luck

(5 years and 3404 days ago)

Girl
avatar erathion
erathion says:

nice idea,try to add some curves to the ribbon,now look a bit flat...good luck

(5 years and 3404 days ago)

Pulpy.......
avatar spaceranger
Moderator says:

Simple color shifting or filter only work won't impress the knowledgeable members. You have to do more with the source.

(5 years and 3404 days ago)

Polution...
avatar Tuckinator

huh cool

(5 years and 3406 days ago)

Pulpy.......
avatar Tuckinator

nicely done!

(5 years and 3406 days ago)

Girl
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

I think stockings need some warping to not seem flat.

(5 years and 3406 days ago)

Girl
no avatar
Widiar says:

Must agree with Warlock. Work with the masks and edges and there is also a huge edge showing part of the dress on her left arm (right side on the screen). The shoes and socks also need some work, shoes especially need some more details. (And agree about the stockings too).

A good idea worth working a bit more..

(5 years and 3407 days ago)

Girl
avatar Warlock
Warlock [banned] says:

Very creative idea still needs a little work tho there is a bit of the dress left behind on the arm, views right her left arm and the fishnet stockings look a bit on the thick side you may want to make them smaller.

(5 years and 3407 days ago)

Girl
avatar Tuckinator

cool

(5 years and 3415 days ago)

rose...
avatar EmiK
EmiK says:

Very cute, and sad, right on theme.

(5 years and 3415 days ago)

Miss u.........
avatar Kid
Kid says:

Shadows might need to be a little darker good luck

(5 years and 3416 days ago)

Miss u.........
avatar Tuckinator

awwwwwwwww... so sad... i like it

(5 years and 3417 days ago)

Miss u.........
avatar itgik
itgik says:

Looks much better, good luck

(5 years and 3418 days ago)

rose...
avatar itgik
itgik says:

I think it would really add to the image if there was a background. I can see the nice work you did to the flower but it seems lacking without the background.

(5 years and 3418 days ago)

rose...
avatar DanLundberg

Need a clear break in the letters where the two covers meet -- as was done with the snowflake-thingy in the center (but with a recognition that the left-side-cover portion needs a shadow from the right-side-cover portion).

(5 years and 3425 days ago)

Photoshop secrets
avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

I'm not sure i understand this entry or how the colour theme fits with the image...

You may want to darken the right hand side of the door, right now the white is a tad overpowering. Also see if you can upload a step by step guide.

Good luck!

(5 years and 3426 days ago)

white room
avatar sunzet
sunzet says:

Cool idea. =)

(5 years and 3427 days ago)

pxl eyes
avatar roon
roon says:

awww for the black eyes.

(5 years and 3428 days ago)

my drawing
no avatar
tbogomo says:

I'm not feeling the "Awww" part. It might be just me, though.

(5 years and 3429 days ago)

my drawing
no avatar

i wont argue now with anyone........................especially on this topic...

sorry i commented on a mistake or a bad practice which tends to block your imagination...
wont do it again....
fine now?

and as for my entry i could have denied it but i didn't because i know and my heart knows that i have not copied it or looked at it more than once....

i think so thats enough for this topic now...
i promise i wont comment on such topics from now on....

(5 years and 3431 days ago)

Kiwirat
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

Author, the next time you do something alike, you have to post the link you use as a reference. It's a good entry, GL!

(5 years and 3431 days ago)

Kiwirat
avatar CrystleClear

^ maybe he looked at the mouse as a reference, just as you did with your entry.

(5 years and 3431 days ago)

Kiwirat
avatar sophia
sophia says:

author you need to submit 2 SBS ( step by step) for your work

(5 years and 3432 days ago)

my drawing
no avatar

@dekwid
naaaa...i did not copied it i just took the idea(dint copied the whole thing)... and not from the link you provided here but saw it in a Photoshop magazine 6....
still got that magazine and its given on page 67.

and secondly i clearly mentioned that i am not saying that its bad to copy or the entry is bad. it helps in learning skills...but it does not enhance the creativity.


anyways the entry here is a ditto duplicate.. thats why i said so....
well you judge it your way and i judge it my way...
i am not a master of Photoshop but i can help others by just telling them how to get the idea and not simply copy them....(because i used to do the same... and i don't deny that i didn't when i started)


and again i say author...you have worked on it and put some efforts i respect that...

(5 years and 3432 days ago)

Kiwirat
avatar dekwid
dekwid says:

>ankitsuhaill,....I think the author didnt copy it on his/her purpose, he/she just just tried to use it as a reference......and I think you did the same once on your entry ' four seasons....four moods', I am sure you got the idea of your work here http://evol1314.deviantart.com/art/MISSING-YOU-37713602?q=1&qo=1, didnt you?

(5 years and 3432 days ago)

Kiwirat
avatar DYNOSSAURUS

I did something similar, in a contest ..... I did not use my creativity.

I was removed.

I agree with ankitsuhaill, but the work is good, ok?

(5 years and 3432 days ago)

Kiwirat
no avatar

cute..hehehe

(5 years and 3432 days ago)

Kiwi dol
no avatar

its really nice
the idea is not yours.... i saw it here
http://browse.deviantart.com/digitalart/photomanip/?q=kiwi&order=9&offset=24#/d196gsn
but still you tried to copy... and managed to do it well
i was thinking of making this but then thought that i should enhance my creativity and make my own thing...

copying makes you learn skills but does not enhance the creativity..

and please do not take my comment in another way
i am not saying its bad or anything like that... the work you have done is quite good
just take care of the blood perspective...

(5 years and 3432 days ago)

Kiwirat
avatar banaalbas
banaalbas says:

lolll

(5 years and 3432 days ago)

Kiwi dol
avatar Kid
Kid says:

Maybe a bg instead of white, but

(5 years and 3436 days ago)

Flower girl.. made by nature
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

Awesome!!! GL!

(5 years and 3436 days ago)

flying fish
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

GL

(5 years and 3438 days ago)

Flower girl.. made by nature
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

The position of the wings is a bit odd; fish is coming, and wings are going - I don't know if you understood me...

(5 years and 3438 days ago)

flying fish
avatar dekwid
dekwid says:

great,...I have seen this kind before on a tutorial in the internet,....

(5 years and 3439 days ago)

flying fish
avatar RAZ0R
RAZ0R [banned] says:

(5 years and 3439 days ago)

Flower girl.. made by nature