629 comments given:
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

This is a nice entry. My only advice would be to skew the shadow on the ceiling to the left somewhat so it is not the same as the shadow on the wall.

(5 years and 3268 days ago)

my mini me
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

The framing and wall are nice touches.

(5 years and 3268 days ago)

Tigmorphin deer
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I really like the atmosphere, depth, and composition of this nicely conceived piece. The people, though, don't work for me.

(5 years and 3268 days ago)

kitrada
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Really cool! Too bad about the air quality. I also feel like there's a reason he/she must look over the shoulder. This would have been a good one for the Post-Apocalyptic contest too.

(5 years and 3268 days ago)

Finding my Color
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Very dynamic! Well done!

(5 years and 3269 days ago)

Eowyn
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I might have nestled the hook a little deeper in the fingers for the grip, but the piece is well chopped. I like it!

(5 years and 3269 days ago)

Looks like a tough guy
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Nice idea. I would suggest a little noise or blur on the human, as he is a little crisp compared to the rest.

(5 years and 3269 days ago)

Wholy Mackerel
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Is that a mouth on her stomach? Anyway, it's creepy and cool. Good luck!

(5 years and 3269 days ago)

Homage to Maria
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Really different. I like it.

(5 years and 3269 days ago)

Money checking system
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I like your composition and unusual color choices, author

(5 years and 3269 days ago)

moon
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Congrats on 3rd!

(5 years and 3271 days ago)

MrM (Bill Maher)
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

First of all, congrats on 3rd place!

A side note to whomever thinks overlaying a piece to check for legitimacy is a negative thing- I have flagged pieces in the past that were indeed traced and they were pulled. I don't tolerate tracing from my students and it has no place here. If you you want to trace, buy a freaking coloring book and some crayons! That being said, I'M GLAD this drawing is legit and I appreciate that greatly!

Author, I hope to see many more from you!

(5 years and 3271 days ago)

Bully
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Congrats mom 'o 4

(5 years and 3271 days ago)

rabbi blowing shofar
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Your Grandson told me to tell you "wow".

(5 years and 3271 days ago)

Still Life with Eggs
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

(5 years and 3272 days ago)

A Bench of Busy Bishops
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

CONGRATS....WELL DONE!

(5 years and 3272 days ago)

An Aurora of Polar Bears
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Could it be.....a young Eddie? It would give me Piece of Mind to know.
Nice work

(5 years and 3273 days ago)

Jaws
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

That's a very unique twist! Nice work, author

(5 years and 3273 days ago)

The Living Mill
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I thought the iris blossoms were chopped from an iris photo!

(5 years and 3274 days ago)

Still Life with Eggs
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Nice concept and composition, author.

(5 years and 3274 days ago)

A Flight of Stairs
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Really cool. I love the camo.

(5 years and 3274 days ago)

Ant ARMY
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Regarding Keilly22's observation, if you duplicate the background layers that are washed out it should give them more presence & stronger color.

(5 years and 3275 days ago)

Rehabilitation
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

This has great possibilities. The atmosphere is nice also. I might suggest a little cut & paste to rearrange some of the repeated structural shapes and make them more random, since they are randomly collapsed. Unless there is lightning behind us, the girl's hand seems a little bright.

(5 years and 3275 days ago)

Dark destiny
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

This a kinda neat atmosphere, but the the girl is almost one story tall. I think she'd be much better at about 1/2 that size.

(5 years and 3275 days ago)

End
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Awesome ATV, but I wouldn't sit on it!

(5 years and 3275 days ago)

ducANTi
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

This is pretty cool, but I would like it better without total symmetry. The braided steel concept is a good one.

(5 years and 3275 days ago)

Nature vs Tech
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Looks pretty good in low res. Unless the deer(fawn) is mutated, in needs to be way closer, like between the bottom of the picture and the car, because it is huge. It would be shorter than the foreground car, even if standing beside it.
Edit:
I see you've moved the deer up, but its still too big. An adult white tail deer is only 32-44 inches at the shoulder. If you compare that height to a car, it's still quite large.

(5 years and 3276 days ago)

2085
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Well done, and the values are well represented also.

(5 years and 3278 days ago)

Jaded-Lead
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Great job, author! That's a difficult expression to draw. I must confess that I even did an overlay in photoshop to check for tracing evidence. I'm glad it wasn't too good to be true!

(5 years and 3278 days ago)

Bully
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I like this except for where there are masking artifacts on the top part of the top hand.

(5 years and 3279 days ago)

Earth mother is BROKEN
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Nice composition

(5 years and 3279 days ago)

Horror balls
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Really cool!

(5 years and 3279 days ago)

in my dreams
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Nice composition, and a very odd feeling piece of work(in a good way).

(5 years and 3279 days ago)

I Dont Wanna be a Lost Picasso
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

LOL . I haven't heard that song for a LONG time - WMMS I think.

(5 years and 3279 days ago)

Roly Poly Dragonfly Heads
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Love the picture. My only issue that lightning wouldn't cast a shadow on the ground.

(5 years and 3281 days ago)

Tazer
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Is this what Peter Steele looks like now? Nice job.

(5 years and 3281 days ago)

Lestat
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Great composition!. There's a lot going on, but it was softened in all the right places.

(5 years and 3281 days ago)

Glamour
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Nice retro feeling & great theme!

(5 years and 3281 days ago)

Peace
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Very unique approach! ...and you were smoking what? Oh well, nicely rendered.

(5 years and 3281 days ago)

The Buddha Interview
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Very nice!

(5 years and 3282 days ago)

Tulips on Canvas
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I like this image a lot, but I would shift the shadows to the left to go with the light source coming from the right.

(5 years and 3282 days ago)

Snapshots
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Really cool chop.

(5 years and 3282 days ago)

Surgeon
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

This is plain freaky! It makes me think of Pink Floyd for some reason. Well blended, author.

(5 years and 3282 days ago)

Pigmalion
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Ha! A lefty! I like the way you closed the eyes on the subject, author. Great work!

(5 years and 3283 days ago)

rabbi blowing shofar
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I'm not a big fan of random imaginary creatures, but this guy is dynamic and well crafted - artistically rendered and foreshortened - beyond just slapping pieces parts together for a "cute", symmetrical character staring at me....again. I would like to see him in a scene of some type, but the background still works very nicely. Great job!

(5 years and 3283 days ago)

Dude.., Smoking is Injurius...
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Really nice mood and composition. I would look for some shots of real crows or something in the sky, though. I think the bird brushes take away from otherwise nice work.

(5 years and 3283 days ago)

the finder the keeper
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Nice chop, but I agree with greymval. I would use different guys in the background, as that was the first thing I noticed.

(5 years and 3283 days ago)

Conflict zone
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I'll avoid controversial discussions, author, but if I may, I would suggest using your clone stamp to alter elements of your picture that are repeated such as sky/cloud/star patterns and rock strata. IMO, it really adds to a piece's realism when objects can be"randomized" and given identity as unique entities. With a little practice, you can achieve good results that way, and relatively quickly. There are some light issues as mentioned, but I do like your mood and composition. Happy chopping!

(5 years and 3285 days ago)

A Dream
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

This is beautiful, but I'm confused. I'm having trouble seeing snow, and when I go to high res. it looks like it's filtered. Please explain if you will.

(5 years and 3286 days ago)

Twins
avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

Very nice composition.

(5 years and 3287 days ago)

Winter landscape