1936 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar arca
arca says:

You have made a very complex image here and I see what you are trying to achieve.

IMO there are a few things that need to be corrected if you have the time.

The masking/cutout of the lady on the left could use some refining (if you can try using layer mask they can help refine the cut). The floor is a little too Cloned looking, you could try to use the cut and paste-over in small section, then position the bricks so they line up (which takes a fair bit of time) or try to get a full brick floor. The base could use a bit of perspective fixing ... the sides are slopping out a bit too much, I would say the upper-far corners could be moved in toward the center of the image a bit (using the Transform tool and hold down the Ctrl key to Free Transform individual corners). You can also see through the left hand side of the base at the back just in front of the lady (a quick way to fix this is just to duplicate the layer until it becomes solid and then merge the layers together). I know this is a lot but your idea is very nice and I believe you are headed in the right direction. If you have any questions just PM me

(5 years and 3052 days ago)

goodbye old friend
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Interesting effect, but the image itself doesn't really "tell a story" or illustrate any type of "fantasy."
It is essentially just a bird gimmicked up with a glow and a bunch of swirly brushwork beneath it.

An effect, does not a "Fantasy SCENE" make. Re-read the contest description, and the emphasis on "scene."

(5 years and 3053 days ago)

firebird.
avatar Hayato
Hayato says:

AH~ thank you, author... you've made me gain a quite interesting inspirations for the contest... XD

(5 years and 3054 days ago)

firebird.
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Cool - love your Audri in the Autumn! Little Shop of Horrors was a great movie, with Steve Martin.

(5 years and 3056 days ago)

FEED ME!!!!!
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

WOW so cute! great work! Congrats!

(5 years and 3056 days ago)

morning break
avatar madamemonty

Congrats, nice work

(5 years and 3056 days ago)

morning break
avatar Drivenslush

CONGRATS!

(5 years and 3056 days ago)

morning break
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Sweet, well chopped!

(5 years and 3056 days ago)

morning break
avatar bcabilan
bcabilan says:

Cute little birdie, nice usage of source image. GL!

(5 years and 3056 days ago)

morning break
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Really fun job! The hole needs to show some thickness, otherwise well done.

(5 years and 3058 days ago)

morning break
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Wow, the early bird catches the worm

(5 years and 3058 days ago)

morning break
avatar Drivenslush

Pretty lady in the sky!

(5 years and 3059 days ago)

star dreamer
avatar Drivenslush

How fantastically cute!!! Great Job!

(remember the sbs!)

EDIT: I figured .. can't wait.. hehehe.. love the birdy!!!

(5 years and 3059 days ago)

morning break
avatar aheman
aheman says:

change title "among the stars"

feel that the moon should be on the left, as if the lady is doing a "moon-dance" to please the Gods. Make the moon whiter and a better glow (however due to the lighting on the lady, it may not be a good idea, on 2nd tots)

arch the carpet or curl it a little, will be more natural

(5 years and 3060 days ago)

star dreamer
avatar Hayato
Hayato says:

The moon kinda plain... And there's a slight of straight lines on the right.

(5 years and 3061 days ago)

star dreamer
avatar aheman
aheman says:

ooh.... its perfect now, go frame it up and CONGRATS!

(5 years and 3061 days ago)

claimed by the sea
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

Congrats

(5 years and 3063 days ago)

claimed by the sea
avatar Drivenslush

Congrats!!

(5 years and 3063 days ago)

claimed by the sea
avatar DanielaOwergoor

Beautiful image!

(5 years and 3064 days ago)

Dream catcher
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Why too late to fix...don't you save layers? If not this should be a lesson. Being able to tweak entries is always helpful.

(5 years and 3065 days ago)

Dream catcher
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Yep, the woman should move back a bit, but good idea.

(5 years and 3066 days ago)

Dream catcher
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

This is very lovely, but the dream catcher is too close to the woman, it looks like the feathers are balancing the entire thing on the top of her head...

Great work on the subtle background image.

(5 years and 3066 days ago)

Dream catcher
avatar aheman
aheman says:

suggestions:
1) underwater feel, should include glistening to the mermaid
2) make hair more "lighter" (now looks heavy, too thick) and free flowing
3) the dangling sea-plants should have different shades of green to create depth
4) trailing bubbles around arms and tail, to create sense of movement
5) lift up the abdomen of the mermaid to make her more shapely
6) add some fish near her, both infront and behind her

hope these suggestions are useful

(5 years and 3066 days ago)

claimed by the sea
avatar Akassa
Akassa says:

Her body looks too small and not proportional to the rest of it. Lovely concept and coloring.

(5 years and 3068 days ago)

claimed by the sea
avatar arca
arca says:

Sorry to hear about the crash ... what a drag!

(5 years and 3072 days ago)

serpents garden
avatar greymval
greymval says:

We only ask for Hi-res to have a better look at your mistakes! MUHAHAHA !
Just kidding author.
Light is coming from above so you should apply highlights & shadows on the body of the dragon considering that.
Imagine the body of the dragon as a torus and it will be easier to shade it, same with his face.
You can use either dodge/burn, or separate clipping layers with white& black to create values - that's my favorite technique.

(5 years and 3073 days ago)

serpents garden
avatar arca
arca says:

Hi res would be really nice ... hard to vote without seeing the detail. Looks like you have done a lot of work and I think you would get a better score with a Hi res. I will wait in hopes that you are able to get one uploaded

(5 years and 3073 days ago)

serpents garden
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

congrats

(5 years and 3076 days ago)

bearly alone
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

congrats

(5 years and 3076 days ago)

sandy beach owls
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!!

(5 years and 3076 days ago)

bearly alone
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!!

(5 years and 3076 days ago)

sandy beach owls
avatar Rod13
Rod13 says:

Really cute.

(5 years and 3078 days ago)

sandy beach owls
avatar Rod13
Rod13 says:

Fantastic vision there author. Best of luck.

(5 years and 3078 days ago)

winging it alone
avatar ramesan
ramesan says:

very nice work author ....best of luck!!

(5 years and 3078 days ago)

broken hearted tears
avatar ramesan
ramesan says:

super work author...GL

(5 years and 3078 days ago)

broken hearted tiny tot
avatar ramesan
ramesan says:

nice one

(5 years and 3078 days ago)

sandy beach owls
avatar ramesan
ramesan says:

very nice work!!

(5 years and 3078 days ago)

bearly alone
avatar ramesan
ramesan says:

Beautiful work author!!

(5 years and 3078 days ago)

winging it alone
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Fabulous piece of work author...well done

(5 years and 3079 days ago)

sandy beach owls
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Fantastic work author...well done

(5 years and 3079 days ago)

bearly alone
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Very interesting work author...gl

(5 years and 3079 days ago)

winging it alone
avatar erathion
erathion says:

fantastic work on a boy and the teddy, with some other background this could be perfect...best of luck author

(5 years and 3079 days ago)

broken hearted tiny tot
avatar erathion
erathion says:

very very interesting work...gl author

(5 years and 3079 days ago)

broken hearted tears
avatar Drivenslush

very nice image.. woo HOO

(5 years and 3079 days ago)

winging it alone
avatar kushpatel
kushpatel says:

like your work author gl..

(5 years and 3079 days ago)

bearly alone
avatar kushpatel
kushpatel says:

nice work author..

(5 years and 3079 days ago)

winging it alone
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The rainbow and sparkle look strange suddenly beginning in front of the winged horse, there is no source of where it comes from. And since it is on top of the flying image, it is not a "path," but something overlaid on top of them...Visually confusing.

(5 years and 3080 days ago)

winging it alone
avatar Akassa
Akassa says:

I think it's a bit too dark but great concept and use of the source.

(5 years and 3080 days ago)

winging it alone
avatar greymval
greymval says:

Lol, what an expression

(5 years and 3081 days ago)

broken hearted tiny tot
avatar Rod13
Rod13 says:

I think it is really neat how several different people can look at something and get different things out of it. Fantastic job on the bear. Good Luck to you.
This would make a really great ID photo for you.

(5 years and 3082 days ago)

bearly alone