438 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar JoeCacia
JoeCacia says:

Nice try author! It looks like it took a lot of your time! Best of luck!

(5 years and 3032 days ago)

Tribill
avatar designed
designed says:

Hi

If it is meant to be a flower , y giving that green shape to much glowing .....i barely can see the flower

good luck

(5 years and 3032 days ago)

Leaflower
avatar kushpatel
kushpatel says:

good one author..

(5 years and 3034 days ago)

Tribill
avatar aheman
aheman says:

nice attempt..if the background can change to a more suitable one, such as a village or something

(5 years and 3035 days ago)

Tribill
avatar JoeCacia
JoeCacia says:

This is soooo cool!

(5 years and 3039 days ago)

Fly away
avatar JoeCacia
JoeCacia says:

It looks like they are going to attack the referee! lol
Best of luck author!

(5 years and 3040 days ago)

Referee is the star!
avatar Derivatix
Derivatix says:

great work and very imaginative. Like it a lot.

(5 years and 3041 days ago)

Fly away
avatar hereisanoop

lol..

(5 years and 3042 days ago)

Referee is the star!
avatar hereisanoop

good job .. he he

(5 years and 3042 days ago)

Fly away
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Imaginative and cute!

(5 years and 3042 days ago)

Bult Plant
no avatar

I agree witn DS. this is a fun and great use of the source author I like the colours you have used for the "flowers" .
GL...

(5 years and 3042 days ago)

Bult Plant
avatar Drivenslush

Very clever use of source author, very nice work and idea

(5 years and 3042 days ago)

Bult Plant
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The background is very crude looking, and even with the reflections, the stools look like they are floating. The separation line between the wall and the floor is almost in the center of your image, a compositional "no no," as it bisects the image.
It's an original idea, but the techinical execution leaves something to be desired, and only using the source image does not warrant much.

(5 years and 3043 days ago)

Hi kids.. look how we...
avatar Drivenslush

I like it! very nice manipulation, the slight motion blur is a nice touch GOOD LUCK

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Fly away
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

His right arm is evidently dislocated at the shoulder...
The sky is too green, and the ring ropes have some lighting consistency and blur issues...
Interesting concept, but it needs work...

(5 years and 3044 days ago)

Referee is the star!
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

I liked it much better without the too heavy yellow light. It doesn't match the tone of the rest of the image and is distracting from the fine effort creating the interior.

(5 years and 3045 days ago)

Fly away
avatar neo2011
neo2011 says:

nice work author gl

(5 years and 3046 days ago)

Fly away
avatar Rod13
Rod13 says:

Cool adding the birds to the picture.

(5 years and 3068 days ago)

Bridge
avatar aheman
aheman says:

just spotted, the nearest pillar's perspective should be the same as the one behind

(5 years and 3070 days ago)

Bridge
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

I see a reflection in the water of the seagull, but I don't think that that should be visible... the shadows are too big, the road is too deformed and the arches need some improvement.

(5 years and 3070 days ago)

Bridge
avatar aheman
aheman says:

cute.......improve the water at the edges of the pillars

(5 years and 3071 days ago)

Bridge
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The white lines are crooked and sloppy looking, and the "roads" are not even in width proportion.

Cute concept, but the execution of it needs work.

(5 years and 3071 days ago)

Bridge
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Try to find a real bird, and un-squish the car. Might want to add shadows to the arches you made, too...

(5 years and 3071 days ago)

Bridge
avatar trim49
trim49 says:

I agree with MossyB.

(5 years and 3150 days ago)

My Old days
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Great concept, but the hair and beard have lost all depth, and are just black masses...Maybe you can go in and add some individual hair back, so it doesn't just look like black paint on the photo.

(5 years and 3150 days ago)

My Old days
avatar Drivenslush

very you author... congrats LOL

(5 years and 3154 days ago)

Vehicle Post
avatar swordfish
swordfish says:

Gud Luck to u author ..........

(5 years and 3158 days ago)

Waiting!
avatar George55
George55 says:

Looks nice to me. The light effect works well. Good luck.

(5 years and 3160 days ago)

Waiting!
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Author, please pay attention to light & shadow. It makes all the difference. You still have plenty of time to revise this. GL.

(5 years and 3163 days ago)

Waiting!
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The lighting on the figure does not correspond to the background image at all, and the added "light beam" makes no visual sense in addition to not illuminating the figure correctly.

(5 years and 3163 days ago)

Waiting!
avatar rbsgrl
rbsgrl says:

Very interesting!! Good Luck!

(5 years and 3184 days ago)

Tangled
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Though they're a little out of proportion, I like the skates and turbo-vehicle. Nice idea for this, author.

(5 years and 3187 days ago)

Where to put!!?
avatar hereisanoop

ha...ha.., very nice..... never expected its you man...

(5 years and 3188 days ago)

Magic carpet
avatar erathion
erathion says:

cool creature author...gl

(5 years and 3191 days ago)

Tomato guy!
avatar petersheep

Maybe if you put a background in this image, changed the color of the floor, everything is red, a little more work the lights and shadows, I believe will get a more realistic result. Good Luck

(5 years and 3192 days ago)

Tomato guy!
avatar hereisanoop

Very nice job man.., good luck

(5 years and 3192 days ago)

Tomato guy!
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Very cool work author...great colors too...GL

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Hell knob!
avatar arca
arca says:

Wonderful detail and a very delicate touch! Don't know about "real" or "not real" but I do know that it look almost surreal to me and I find the lighting works.

(5 years and 3194 days ago)

Threaded flower
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Crazy gladiator

(5 years and 3194 days ago)

Why are you here?!
avatar swordfish
swordfish says:

Nice imagination and well constructed image author ......all the best to u .....

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Threaded flower
avatar Drivenslush

MossyB.. well from your statement, calling this a CBR'd piece is incorrect, and then saying your sorry for ripping into it with a confidence only seen in the likes of Bill O'reilly is down right weird, not to mention calling it NOT COHESIVE when it's in the shape of a triangle, one of the most balanced forms in the universe (check out the Last Supper) leaves your comment somewhat to be desired.. but then again this is IMHO.. this is a very excellent chop, and it made grand use of the source.. complimenting it, then calling it a doodle, is just not that cool

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Threaded flower
avatar ibmaxed
ibmaxed says:

Agree with Drivenslush...top job author. Your lighting is fine, reality does not always have to play in these images.

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Threaded flower
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

I FULLY understand "non-representational," DrivenSlush. That has nothing to do with my comments to the AUTHOR, but thank you for presuming to educate me.

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Threaded flower
avatar hereisanoop

Good job machaaa...

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Hell knob!
avatar Drivenslush

Excellent construction and I can see the source perfectly, and i can see it all through the please.. the original image is clearly visible...

the lighting is perfectly fine for a frontal flash, great job author

the triangular construction is very well balanced and cohesive, and nothing is flat,

I really like the work author, and the entire image is completely yours and you didn't have to "borrow" an image from a stock site

and don't be sorry MossyB, Just try to learn more about non representational-ism, it's in every hotel and hospital waiting room in the Art Deco district of South beach, and this image would fit in perfectly

Great Job AUTHOR.. good luck

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Threaded flower
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Creative for a CBR, but the lighting and shadows are totally inconsistent, with the black background only adding to the visual confusion.

It's imaginative and creative, but not cohesive as a visual image - I'm sorry, but it's like a "Photoshop doodle."

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Threaded flower
avatar Geexman
Geexman says:

Nice crisp image, I like it.....slight nit pick is bring the interlocking sections of the chain closer so they just touch then add a little burn where they meet, but thats a very minor criticism. Great Job author

(5 years and 3196 days ago)

Hell knob!
avatar rbsgrl
rbsgrl says:

This is awesome!

(5 years and 3198 days ago)

Blue Globe
avatar dannifood4less

looks like a playstation 3 platinum trophy! :thumbs up:

(5 years and 3198 days ago)

Blue Globe
avatar nishagandhi

cool work

(5 years and 3198 days ago)

Why are you here?!