lol ... let me get this clear, I asked if you had illustrated it, you lied and said yes & offered to fake an SBS to prove you had. Then I produce the brush you used for said illustration. You admit you lied but blame me for not pointing out your dishonesty sooner? ... yeah I can see how I could be at fault here.

good luck

actually I was saying oops about the tree brush... you have to include all sources used to make an entry. I did look at your sbs, so it wasn't a knee jerk reaction... there is nothing about the tree in there. So I still say OOPS.

oops!

Thanks for going to great detail to show your "illustration technique", Judging by your SBS you "illustrated" this specifically for the bra to fit the girl? but I cant understand why in high res there is an the outline of previous bikini straps, this usually occurs when you use the magic wand tool to remove colour then the fill tool to replace it with skin colour, the straps also dont feature anywhere in your sbs. Also from steps 3-12 you seem to have coloured between her legs a small patch of scarlet which looks the same shade as the outline I mentioned. Just to add insult to injury you claim to have Illustrated the palm tree, yet I know it is brush 1144 from this brush set http://www.brusheezy.com/brushes/1312-Complete-Tree-Brush-Pack, this breaks the rules as a brush set is a source.

it is nice but something missing ,and i'm soory becaous i don't know what is missing

Very nice indeed, I`m guessing you illustrated the palm tree too?

Did you draw this? If so please post SBS...if not post source link.

Don't feel too bad... You'll get over it. Like me

GL

Very good!

Good job! =)

Nice idea! =)

I suppose it's raining in center panel... but CMYK asked a good question: why only 3 seasons? It's a very good idea, and beautiful manipulations, so, you could complete it with all seasons...

woow, awesome trick

very nice

great idea- only one thing IMO ,the sky in the winter is clear and cloudy in the spring and on the whole image the mountains don't flow with the rest of the image. suggestion: loose the mountains in the winter or clear up the sky's in the spring

Nicely done

Very nice work author...best of luck

Only 3 seasons? Why the blur in the center panel?

Beautiful....

this a great idea. but it looks a little bland for chocolate.

nice one...gl

(GMTCBR)........... just kidding....... gl

hang in there Author

nice concept but waaaay too blurry

I think the crisper flowers overpower the pale, ghostly bird and become the focus of attention.

Loving this dreamy environment...

author.. if you are not after votes that is totally respected in my book.. I find some times it's better to go against the flow and you will retain you're own unique style...BUT if you do want higher votes you can just introduce the source into the back ground (where it looks LIKE the source) but this is totally up to you.. but I do ask you NOT to throw your hands up and say.. Oh this site is buggar.. I would like to see MORE of your work.. so I can have a better base field of judging your work (not that I judge.. I'm too busy Yapping LOL) (and I never do well.. LOL. but that's what I like about me..)

Still your color choice on this piece are quite wonderful.. the over all balance of powder blue with the baby pink is quite pretty)

good LUCK!!!

this is pretty much CBR

Sorry, but you didn't use the cross. I agree with bjaockx---you used the color white. I think you're missing the point of what a photoshop contest is meant to be--just look at other people's entries.

hmm... did you really need the Celtic cross in order to create this image? perhaps you could have had the bird you created sitting on the cross instead of a branch... either way imo the source was not used at all... only the color white was used.

and where is the celtic cross?

Mine too, Joshua. This really needs an SBS or it could get disqualified.

minimal source used, IMO (in my opinion)

post an SBS, and maybe try to add more depth to the shapes

Edit; SBS stands for Step By Step Guide

Nice...but couldn't you have done this with ANY picture?