congrats Rob!

Ha, clever

Fantastic work

very nice work...like the hand and smoke so much...good luck

It looking so realistic...

Very nice image and great result. Good Luck

Very good work!!

i like that smoke...... great work

Nice work , good luck.

Good work, I like the shadow under the hat and the smoke

Good blend and best idea so far.

Fotunately my cigarettes isn't Camel... Stunning work!

I scored you high nice job

very good work!

Even though the blend is not very good, but the concept and overall look is superb. Well done!

Excellent work.

Maybe this will help some folks STOP smoking!! Wonderful job! GL

heehee...cool

The wrist looks a bit thin to me, but the rest is excellent! Great, GREAT job!

Edit: I have to keep coming back to look at this!! Really well done entry.. the attention to detail shows a lot of skill... Good luck

Congratulations!

Congrats!

Congrats

Congrats!

congrats on second unique idea and nice execution

Congrats,

Congrats for your second place, Solkee!

congrats Rob!

hahaah awsome , the idea is the best in this category..

I think you nailed it! Well done and good luck!

Great work. Good luck

Great image!

great job!!

I like this

THe shadows look a little weird but other than that, well done!

There are a few focal problems regarding the trees... also some blending withe the source... also i think there should be a shadow somewhere for the tortoises head. (it's not a turtle people!!)... I do really like the concept though!!!! GL!!... (and also, though its a fantasy scene and you want to keep the sky... i think you should atleast add a slight hint of that colour overall!)

nice idea author.... and well executed to me

love the idea! great job!

sweet! lol some places they do the same thing with folks that think different. Great image author made me wince!

I love this idea! Nicely composited, too.

great thinkin . but sky is not matchin with the whole enviroment n light. have a look ..good luck

Great idea! Back edge of shell needs more shadow...compare to buildings.

Great chop and idea. Ilke it

great mood!!

Nice idea. something left at left center of image, may be part of cloud layer. Shadow of face/head is also missing.

You could have blended Giallo's head a little better.

hahaha!!! or should I say... HOHOHO? ))) and they didn't want to hire me this year either for Santa's helper... they have no idea what they're missing! hm!

Very funny, but that's a really bad job of blending Giallo's head...

Giallo is tha man! Good luck!

Congrats

congrats! for 2nd place.