The people are too stretched out, but the idea is good. Also she looks like she's walking on water, maybe because of the desaturation...

Interesting concept, but fully agree with elemare. I'd go for some more higher quality images, keep them in the right proportions (press shift while scale images) and try to match the light from added images compared to the source image. Good luck!

idea is good, but the picture is compressed

Good Luck

good luck

First, author, both the image of the man and the woman are rights-managed. Do you have permission to use them? Rules are, you have to show proof of authorization or payment receipt in the SBS. Once you're over that potentially disqualifying hurdle, next, the concept is good, but to make it work successfully: 1. re-add the man and woman from the original source, making sure they are in correct proportion (they are too "tall" or "skinny"right now to be natural); desaturate the woman to make her grayscale like her background. There are also some light source/shadow issues. Good luck!

Interesting...

those people look a tad bit distorted

I like this concept! I think it would be even more effective if the woman was monochromatic like her surroundings. Good job!

the people are very blury. The light on the girl doesn't seem to match the picture well. Good job on placing them so they look like they are walking in the water.

they're a bit stretchy.. remember to hold down the shift key when transforming so they don't lose their proportions... good luck!!