267 comments given:
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I don't really think that your class is thick like this. In my opinion, if I explain your problems, and give some advices how to make better, you learn more, as if I make a comment like above, about how good is.

So I explain why isn't correct this scene, and you should remember my advises in the future.

The main problem is that everything is thick, this could be adjusted easily, just have to notice it.

The second problem is the sharp of the edges, use chamfer tool on every edges that are too close to camera.

Use texture on models, CGTtextures is full of textures of all the genres, and it's free. Nearly every texture has at least a minimal reflection, don't forget this, your floor will be much more realistic with a blurry reflection, under the right window.

Best wishes.

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

my school
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

The first problem is i think the color of the walls. Why is tha left wall yellow?

You should create with line tool a cable at least for the keyboard.

Your edges are too sharp, always use on it chamfer tool, 1 cm 2 segments.

The lights are ok, but the textures has no reflections.

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

school lab.
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

If this is really one of your first 3d model than I would like to congratulate.

There are some problems, but if you have less then 50 hours experience this work is the very best.

Let's start with the main problem, this table can not be presented in a simple white or black background render. Here you should put this table near a wall textued with white tiles... it would be much more natural.

I think you used scanline render or maybe mental ray, but you do not checked the shadow option, so your models seems to be levitating instead of being in the table.

If you do not remember something, you should search something similar on google, this is totally legal.

I hade made some major problems in modelling, if you want some advices how to make things easier, contact me.

Best wishes.

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

Chemistry station
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

You should use some reflections on the materials, the models are quite simple, but it's quite ok.

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

class room
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I think this entry was off topic.

Your shadows are too sharp, the mouse and keyboard has unreal shapes, the keyborad should be more wide, and the mouse is too small. The shaders are incorrect too, never use fully black color, in the real word isn't full black color.

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

Best in 3D contest
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

Don't forget to use chamfer too, don't let the edges to be sharp like hell. Dirt map will help to make your materials more realistic, try to use it.

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

The Big Screw
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

Can you explain the rule of the basic teapot at this scene?

The texture of the wall is too big, I do not saw any bump on it, the teapot has no material at all, the most realistic is the match.

Try practicing the materials, even if you have good models, if the shaders are shitty, the whole scene will be unreal.

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

Order Of The Empty Roll
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

The woman in the picture is your photo? If not you are able to use it?

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

Teacher
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

Nice work, the color correction is really intimate.

(5 years and 2478 days ago)

treasure
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

The materials at the propeller and in the tyres are incorrect, the propeller does not have any reflection, and in the tyer, is too sharp. The lights are ok. The model is good too, but that is not your work, so do not count.

(5 years and 2486 days ago)

Spitfire
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I think there are some problems with the textures, first the asphalt texture is wrapped horizontally, but the main problem is with the texture of the car, it is too matte, I saw your first version of it, and there were much greater textures on it.

(5 years and 2488 days ago)

Left behind.
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I don't really like the way that you used the lights, and the little waterdrops are too similar and/or regular. The bottle is ok, and I like the logo on it.

(5 years and 2488 days ago)

The original lager beer
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

The material of the umbrella is quiet saturated, you could apply on it a color filter in ps, and the shadow is too sharp, watch the shadow of the moped, it is much more blurrier.

(5 years and 2488 days ago)

Red Umbrella
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

"The Picture MUST be taken outside and it MUST be raining, not just a cloudy day."

For me it seem like a simple cloudy day, otherwise the picture is great, but a little bit off topic.

(5 years and 2493 days ago)

Outside the Luwr
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

this shot totally gives the feeling that this is an old ancient shelf.

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Back in the days
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

It gives a very strange feeling about, the dungeons

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

dungeon access
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

nice shot, the lighting is perfect

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Orange
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I like the repeat of the trees, the green colour is nice, and gives a little sad mood to the picture.

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Trees
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

Super shot, great colour harmony, nice idea, great realization.

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Playing alone
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

wonderful shot, i can't imagine how u created the falling water drops, grat.

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Got thirsty?
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

The idea was ok, a little bit similar with mine's, but this is another perception. With this background the whole picture seems a little bit amateur, You should use a dark sheet, in the right side of the monitor, for background, to felt the artistic way of this picture.

(5 years and 3182 days ago)

Internet Bear
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

erathion, can i ask you why do you comment the same thing for the whole entries? You are a talented user, if you like something i think you could write down why do you prefer that work.

(5 years and 3183 days ago)

Internet Bear
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

beautiful, i try this filter in my pictures too

(5 years and 3191 days ago)

glowing
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

wow, beautiful colour

(5 years and 3191 days ago)

Flower
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

suuper shot grat

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Spring
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

i think it's so usual, you can play with the lights

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Spring
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

There should be very dark ) the picture is noisy, but one of the bests. Garat. the light areperfect.

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

old
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

oldtimer these types will won here

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Old American
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

unbealivable shot, notthe car is in the main focus, but i like it!

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

BMW Horizon
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I saw this photo somewhere, in i wrote there too that is wonderful

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Thirsty
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

it seems like a vulcan in the deep

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Late at night...
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I like the perspective

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Memorial Portrait
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

like a frame from a film

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Dream in portrait
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

wow, big grat for the author, it's funny, the SBS, i think i cant guess never that u used a sponge for ground

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

1st Eleven
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I dont really understand first what u want to imagine, after the sbs i was enlightened

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Can you guess?
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

) very big idea ) with the chocolate , and the lightning, grat

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Shocking
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

My opinion is that here is too much the black, and do not happen anything. You should imagine a scene with these "animals"

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Odd Group
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I like the idea ) first i thought that is a real picture.

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

My favourite painting
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

the whole frame is filled, i like it, there are no unnecessary space

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Fizz!
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

nice trick ) good idea, good result

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

reflection
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

simple and creative, but the left downside of the picture is a little bit boring.

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Wine anyone?
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

It"s a nice "colourful" picture, one colour, but that is the dominating colour, and it"s good positioned, not the center, but yet )

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

dried
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

With a little higher contrast the shadow should be stronger, and i think it would be better.

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

shadow berries
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

This picture gives me a very good idea, to my shadow topic, i just have to wait for the sun.

Nice pic, but it"s a little bit boring, you should use something + in the back, in which the shadow has a different effect.

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

ribbon shadow
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

the red numbers gives something + that makes the picture awareness

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Crackberry
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

This pic is a little bit simple, but the strange contrast is interesting

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

nameless
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

This should be the most dramatic piano lesson in the world ) but the picture is ok.

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Piano lessons
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

I don't know what means that key, but the orange colour is interesting. You should raise a little bit the contrast, to highlight more the orange buttons with the strange colour.

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Computer keyboards
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

Grat, for this shot.

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Broken memories.
avatar trialboj
trialboj says:

wonderful landscape

(5 years and 3201 days ago)

Viewpoint