It's very good, but those horisontal lines are so distracting... =/ Also, some cloning/stamping is clearly visible in some parts (you can spot where it was cloned without even seeing the original), so I'd fix that. But don't get me wrong I still like it very much, I'm just to nitpicky. =)

Very very good! Good job!

Wow, it's brilliant!!! Wow!

Uhhh, that's not a reflection.... the angle of incidence should be the same as angle of reflection.... Meaning it should be vertical in this case...

It's fantastic!!!

WOOOOOOOOOOOOW!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'm.... How did you.... WOW!!! *speechless* It's amazing! Winner!

Wow, really awesome! gl!

Very nice. =)

It's beautiful. And I know the feeling.... Today is the first time I experienced it... Wonderful.... ='(

Very good. gl!

Good work! Makes me wanna get vray sooo bad, I'm still stuck with the default scanline renderer.... GL!!

Hah, interesting! I like it! =)

Interesting =)

Hahah, very interesting! And I just love zuma-like games!! =)

Nice =) Simple but effective =)

OK, now I'm satisfied ^_^ Awesome image, definitely the winner. =)

Indeed. Very good model, but lighting needs to be better. It's a shame when good models look bad because of bad lighting. Keep it up! =)

Very, very good model! Just please put the sky and tweak lighting a bit, and it'll be awesome! =)

Very very good, but I'm holding my vote until I see a full SBS. =)

Nice work, congrats, I just hope it's fair, since you didn't show how you made the bridge, plants and the background stuff in SBS.... But congrats anyway!!! =)

This is really beautiful work, but I just hate when people take some minor parts and transform it into something that has nothing to do with it. You could've done this even if the source was a blank white image. It shows skills, but these kind of images are more suited to a theme contest than to source... =/

The model is good, but you have to work on shadowing...

WOW. Absolutelly brilliant shot!!!

Wow, it's wonderful!!! I'd say it's a bit too dark in some parts, so if you're allowed to edit it, I'dbrighten it up just a liiiitle bit, but it's great anyway! Winner. =)

Wow, I just LOVE this one! So unique and different from the others, a very good contrast between the mud and the rest of the image, really really best one. Winner. =)

Ooooh, I just love this one! It's really really nice, and perfectly fits the theme!

My favourite so far! ^_^

OMG. Like you literally stole my idea! But anyway, it's very very good, GL!

Hmmmm, very very intgeresting approach! I like the style, tho I'd use a slightly bigger field of view for the camera, and maybe a bit more contrast. GL!

Wooooow! Awesome! Winner.

What, nothing else to say? Nothing to back it up? Silence speaks the volume.....

Continued... You are contradicting yourself genuine. Everyone has an opinion? Well, so do I. It's a contest, and I'm giving my constructive opinion, that's why it's called 'COMMENTS', and that's why they exist. Stop checking my every comment and trying to disapprove it! And the author was the one who started this argument in the first place. You may beg for my pardon but you won't get it. I did not threat you, and I'm willing to show publicly all the PMs we exchanged, and let the people decide if you think it was a threat. The world doesn't spin around me, but it seems that you do. Grow up.

WHAT?!?! I never threatened you, you're an idiot and you don't know English. I told you it's not a threat, it's how you say it, I said: "Hey, I just gave you a friendly advice about rules.... Don't blame me later when you get your images taken off the contests..... ". Anyone with a slightest knowledge of English knows this is not a threat!! Next, about my comments here, I did not neglect authors opinions, neither I said the world spins around me. I just gave him an advice how to make the image better. And get rid of me, you really tend to 'follow' me on here and disagree with me on everything.

Looks better now =)

Hmmmm, interesting. Very nice! =)

ego-centrism and ignorance... miserable.... just ignore.

Hey, calm down man! I was just trying to help for goodnes sake! Instead of being a dick and just flagging the image, I tend to help and be constructive first. So take a chill pill, it's not world's end if someone criticizes your work! Learn to accept it.

Wow, this is truly epic! Very good idea, I like it!

Very good, I like the colors very much!

Cool effect, but how does this relate to exo planets? Off theme.... =/

Nice idea and perspective, but I'd fix colors and exposure a bit. Add a little contrast, it's kinda washed out, but besides that it's great.

I was reffering to the shadows of plants, animals and such, but i see that you have already correctd that, cause when I commented they were really low-detailed. I know what bumpmaps are. =)

It's great except the shadows, they look like squares.

Congrats on the win Missy!!

Hahaha, it's great! =D

Oh, the rules must've been changed the last time I saw them.... It's OK then, I love it!

WOW! It's AWESOME!!!!!!! But, you're not allowed to edit it in photoshop or similar, you can only tweak brightness contrast and similar, no colour changing, no other editing.... =/ So, you should really do it without, I'm sure it looks fabulous without the effects, after all, you got Vue GL!

It's great now!! =D

WOW, this is awesome! I'd just bring up the saturation and contrast a little bit, and make the water more bloue-ish and reflective, but otherwise, it's great!

Wow! Great!